• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Keeping the proper weight on your puppy or dog

immortaldobes

Well-Known Member
Note: the following comments were moved from another thread because this is an important topic on weight gain in puppies and dogs and it deserves more conversation without taking the original thread too far off topic. :)

Wow, him and Albert are almost identical in weight too. I like to keep them lean too (or at least not chubby) since I don't want to risk pano, hip problems or just general health problems as they grow. They will fill out with maturity, so I'm not going to push it right now. :)
You got that right!!! He is big enough as it is!! LOL
 
Pano contrary to popular misconception is not a result of weight in a puppy, its in direct relation to how TALL they grow in this phase of their life. Its the leggier puppies like Danes', IW, Dobies, Boxer's, Mastiff's etc that grow FAST and tall all at once... the puppies that you see pulling up with pano are the leggier of the puppies.
Weight will affect their joints like shoulders, hips and elbows if they work or are incredibly active at this age and are heavier than their frame can hold... thinness is not a ''healthy' condition Ladies.. keeping your dog 'lean' as an adult is advantageous as it is for humans, but thinking you are avoiding 'pano' by 'keeping' your puppy 'thin' is a misnomer and a misconception about the things that affect young large breeding fast growing breed puppies.
Ozzy, Buddy and Baba are not 'chubby' puppies because they weigh more than your puppies do.. they are heavier bone by perhaps 1.5 to 2 x's... the bone is the weight not the muscle mass of flesh. Puppys are supposed to be fleshy, and soft and have a bit of 'meat' to them because they grow so fast that they grow out of their 'skin' in a matter of weeks to a month... so keep the proper perspective here.. a 'thin' puppy is not a healthier puppy than a 'thicker or bigger boned' puppy. A mastiff puppy weighs more than a great dane puppy because of their bone size and density...
Ozzy, Buddy and Baba' have very heavy bone and dense bodies by their phenotype, not by their food intake...
Just FYI... :D
 
....
Ozzy, Buddy and Baba' have very heavy bone and dense bodies by their phenotype, not by their food intake...
Just FYI... :D

Funny you say that, Ozzy doesn't eat a massive amount of food compared to some that I've read about, he will have a cup of kibble for breakfast then a further 2 more meals during the day consisting of a cup of kibble and 0.5 Ib meat in each meal, not a huge amount and he's still putting the pounds on...

Saying that it's time for his weekly weigh in, stay tuned :)
 
Funny you say that, Ozzy doesn't eat a massive amount of food compared to some that I've read about, he will have a cup of kibble for breakfast then a further 2 more meals during the day consisting of a cup of kibble and 0.5 Ib meat in each meal, not a huge amount and he's still putting the pounds on...

Saying that it's time for his weekly weigh in, stay tuned :)

Ozzy is a normal healthy well bred European 'heavy phenotype" puppy and will probably have eating bursts now and again.. they often eat alot for periods of time of most intense growth, and some puppies are just not into food at all. Gemma was one of those and now she is a' abject foodie'... she loves it all of it... Baba, eats quite alot and has been rather interested in food since day one. I am of the strong belief that puppies eat because they are hungry till they are about a year old... then they have had enough 'treats' and 'special tasty items' in their life to know what yummy stuff food is.... then they can often become like Gemma and somewhat food obsessed, which if you are training for anything is a good thing to use... Use what motivates them for training! If its food? great. you have a great tool all the time. IF its a tug of war game (as it was Gemma's obsession) then you use that instead of food for the greatest reward.
But withholding food from a hungry puppy because you think he/she 'needs to be thin' is the wrong mentality.
Puppies growing at this point in their life each have an internal barometer of how much food they need to grow and not more. If you feed them a specific amount and they eat every single bite at each meal and still seem hungry? Its because they are...
and should be fed more regardless of what you 'think' is enough for them. Hunger comes from a natural response to an empty stomach at this age and some puppies like Ozzy may be content with 1 cup of food... if I fed Baba only one cup and a half pound of meat? He would be starving to death... He eats 6 cups of food at a time and a half pound of meat and he simply could not survive on 1 cup even if it were 3 times a day. I feed him 2 x's a day and he has about 4-6 cups of kibble if I am feeding kibble that day (Orijen is my kibble) or he gets about 2-3 lbs of raw meat and bone a day if he is eating raw that day... 1-2% of the body weight in raw meat per day or feeding is what is considered a normal amount of food for a carnivore, so 1.5 lbs of food per feeding would be adequate for growth and proper nutrition... giant breeds will eat 2-3% of their body weight per day and usually incorporating 1 day a week of fasting for a true prey model feeding schedule or raw food. Gives them a day to completely purge their system of uric acid from all the meat that they eat daily.
So judging from the size of each of these puppies you see that each one has a different metabolism and ability to process and digest food and a different hunger level. Baba is a hungry dude and he can put away the food, but if you saw him in person, you would see he is lean, muscle mass and a super heavy boned dude who is healthy as a ox and eats like one too... :eek:
 
Great post Diva and I totally agree esp where you say:
If you feed them a specific amount and they eat every single bite at each meal and still seem hungry? Its because they are... and should be fed more regardless of what you 'think' is enough for them.

With Ozzy he eats just enough of what he wants, if he licks his dish clean he will get another cup full until he is satisfied and leaves some.

I also should be more accurate in what I say, my cup is a large mug which is probably equivalent to a measure of cup and a half to 2 cups. Also ahem I should have done my maths better, he has a kilo of meat per day which is 2.2 Ibs, not the 1 pound as I said - my bad....

:whistle:
 
Ahem x2, more embarrassment. Talking to my wife about how much food Ozzy gets she reminds me that he gets treats, a tin of fish, the meaty table scraps which is significant per day and she feeds him 2 'mugs' of kibble with his meat...

Can I start again please...
 
Great post Diva and I totally agree esp where you say:


With Ozzy he eats just enough of what he wants, if he licks his dish clean he will get another cup full until he is satisfied and leaves some.

I also should be more accurate in what I say, my cup is a large mug which is probably equivalent to a measure of cup and a half to 2 cups. Also ahem I should have done my maths better, he has a kilo of meat per day which is 2.2 Ibs, not the 1 pound as I said - my bad....

:whistle:

LOL Marko!! I would measure that cup you use and see what it really is... It could be more than you think!

I use a scoop which is a small reusable plastic bowl which I discovered holds 2 cups of food in a dry measure cup... It looks like it might be a cup, but its double that!
I give him 3 of these scoops with a half pound of ground meat and chicken broth, 2 tblspn's of food yeast and a raw egg often and a spoonful of some bacon grease or chicken grease left over from cooking and kept in fridge. It takes him a while to eat, he does not inhale his food, but he just keeps going back to it over about a 20 minute period of time. Whatever he does not eat in that period? I pick up and leave for later.. usually it is nothing, but sometimes there is about a 1/2 cup or so... so I know he is full.
If eating raw, I give them their raw portions outside in the grass and they take it off to a secret place to eat it. When they are done with that portion I give them another one till I have given them about 2 lbs of meat at a meal. Gemma eats once a day and Baba eats twice... morning around 8:30am and then again around 4pm....
treats in the evening when they come in for the evening and thats it...
they often get a cut up huge apple per evening that they share, and sometimes some watermelon which they absolutely love... they eat about 80-90% raw food all week long and a few days a week they get their 'Orijen' kibble mixed with raw.
 
Gosh Diva, I was in no way insinuating that any of the pups here were over weight, so I hope you didn't take it as such. :) I'm just saying that we keep them at a healthy weight and trust me, Albert gets a high quality food and still eats over 6 cups per day, but it's not like we're going to keep a bowl in front of them 24 hours a day either and let him get obese at this age either. :) I have seen a lot of people over the years with the impression that they have to free feed and they do have overweight pups who turn out to be obese adults down the road and that's not healthy no matter how you slice it. :) Of course many of those people just keep the food bowl full all the time and give them no exercise either so that just intensifies the problem too.
 
Sorry, I just have to chime in again. I don't have a lot of time so it may seem choppy or short, I certainly mean no disrespect to anyone, but had to put in my 2 cents.

ok a couple clarifications- first there was no insinuation of anyone being overweight.

second- You CAN overfeed a puppy, just because a puppy thinks he is still hungry doesn't mean that is what is best for them. When feeding a puppy dry food (as I think a lot of us do), they will keep eating until they "Feel full", unfortunately when the food hits the stomach and starts to swell (picture dropping a kibble in water and watch how much it swells), they end up just poopong it out the back door-this equals wasted food, un needed calories deposited as fat, puppies may start eating their poop because it comes out undigested, more poop to clean and it CAN affect their growth rates which will affect Panosteitis. Puppies will reach a certain size based on their genetics, The more protein they get (also correlation between vit D/ phos ratios), the faster they get there, the more chance they have of developing pano. And when I say I am watching out for their hips in the long run ( I am not talking about Pano)- It is a proven fact in veterinary science that puppies that are allowed to gain too much weight too fast are at a greater risk of developing Hip Dysplasia when they are older. The added weight during puppy hood causes unnecessary concussion on the joints during normal activity.

Again, I never meant to insinuate that anyone was overweight, over feeding, or not doing what they think was best for their dog. I know that everyone on this forum LOVES their dog or why would any of us spend our free time talking about them!! LOL
 
There was some insinuation or at least it 'read' as insinuation and that was why I posted the current posts. Just so we are all clear about our ideas of healthy and overweight and thin and lean etc....
a thin puppy is just as at risk as a 'heavy' puppy for issues related to insufficient nutrition... in the case of most puppies, it is a question of too thin and not to heavy.
Having had Neapolitan mastiffs for over 20 years in addition to Dobermans and Rotties, large breeds run the gamut of size and some mastiff puppies are under weight and most assuredly they can also be over weight but the former is more often the case rather than the latter. The same holds true for Dobie pups...
I see far to many underweight juveniles and young adults than I see overweight ones and I worry more about insufficient nutrition related issues than 'obesity' related issues in this breed.
I see the same problem in Malinois. GSD's, Dutchies, Rotties etc and other working breeds.
I hear people speak or talk about their puppy and are hyper concerned about their 'working dog' being too heavy and simply do not realize that puppies grow so fast at this stage that insufficient caloric intake is far the worse offense...
So, keeping them under weight is not beneficial... as juveniles and young adults... until such time that your dogs are working daily and in competitions regularly and in constant intense training and then you see that you cannot keep weight on, that is a different story than a simple pet puppy growing up in a home that may work them some day and yet you are keeping them 'thin' for their health before they have matured is a far more detrimental condition. UNDER weight is worse.... than over weight..
Over weight by a few pounds can be worked off in a day or two or a week of growth... under weight by a few pounds is seriously jeopardizing their health especially when they are growing at the rates of 4-5 lbs a week as some of these puppies are and what they SHOULD Be gaining for their size.
Just making clear distinctions here between healthy and obsessive about 'thinness' and or 'leanness' in your 'working breed' puppy. :)
 
Diva, no one said they were keeping them "underweight" either. There has to be a balance and that's up to us to keep a close eye on their food intake as they grow every day. Just ask my Hubby how many times I tell him we need to increase the food on a growing pup if they're starting to look thin, or in Della's case cut her back when she became lethargic after losing Boris because she was becoming too heavy for her size. I don't want them either direction, but around here (in our town) at least, the biggest health problem our vet sees is obese dogs, and it seems to be a pattern in many people, so it needs to be publicized both ways. :)

I'm going to move these posts to their own thread so we can keep the puppy weights separate for reference.
 
So I guess chubby children are much healthier as well? I don't think so. Lean children are not lacking in nutrition, and the same goes for puppies. It is a well known back that it is not good for puppies to be overweight while growing as it puts extra strain on their growing bones and joints. Lets face it. They are not heavier just because of heavy bone structure. That doesn't make for a big belly. Sorry but that is just not true. Yo make it sound like all Euro Dobies are chubby, which is not true either. When they have extra weight on them it comes down to fat, plain and simple. I agree that they should not be underweight as they will not be able to build muscle, but it is better to be lean than being overweight, and that goes for any species. Also I do not agree that it is just a matter of the leggier dogs getting Pano. I have never had a dog with Pano and my dogs are always kept lean and fit.

It also comes down to their level of energy if they are overweight or not. They are bound to have more energy when they are leaner and more fit. When we got Easter at 10 months old she had more weight on her than we like, but as she was supposed to be a show dog she had show dog weight. This does not mean that she was obese by any means, she was just heavier than we like. She did not have a lot of energy and since we have gotten her in the condition we like she has abundant energy and can run and run and run. There is a body condition that is the optimal for an athlete and it sure isn't by logging around extra pounds of fat.
 
Having had Neapolitan mastiffs for over 20 years in addition to Dobermans and Rotties, large breeds run the gamut of size
Dobermans are NOT large breed. It is stated quite clearly in the breed descriptions that they are a medium size breed. Are they on the larger end of medium? Yes, but they are still medium. They are not supposed to be 100+ pounds just like they are not supposed to be tiny and lacking in power.
 
Dobermans are NOT large breed. It is stated quite clearly in the breed descriptions that they are a medium size breed. Are they on the larger end of medium? Yes, but they are still medium. They are not supposed to be 100+ pounds just like they are not supposed to be tiny and lacking in power.
What then is considered a "Large Breed"? I would consider them large with the males around 27-28 inches at the shoulder. However, I think that some of the really large dogs like the Irish Wolf Hound and Great Dane lack the brains that the Doberman have :)
 
There is no universal measurement that qualifies as "large" or "giant". However this is from the AKC's description of the Doberman: "A square, medium-sized dog, the Doberman Pinscher is muscular and possesses great endurance and speed." And from UKC "The Doberman Pinscher is a square-bodied, smoothly-muscled, elegant dog of medium size with a short coat." And from the DPCA: "The appearance is that of a dog of medium size, with a body that is square." From a website on judging Dobermans: "Medium size and compactly built. This is a fundamental breed characteristic. The Doberman does not have a size disqualification, but to maintain a medium size dog, with the correct bone, substance and muscle we have a top of 28” for dogs and 26” for bitches. The Doberman must also be built for speed and should not be heavy or cumbersome. Neither should they be refined and spindly." See the repeated "medium"?
 
I would also like to point out that they in Europe are discussing the trend towards the very heavy Dobies we see in Eastern Europe and Russia. That is not what the Dobie is supposed to look like and we need to be careful they don't end up becoming to heavy but stay elegant and athletic like it was intended.

I agree with DreamValley that there is a difference between the NA and the Euro Dobie, but Gino does not look heavy. He looks strong and fit, not overweight. :)
 
There is no universal measurement that qualifies as "large" or "giant". However this is from the AKC's description of the Doberman: "A square, medium-sized dog, the Doberman Pinscher is muscular and possesses great endurance and speed." And from UKC "The Doberman Pinscher is a square-bodied, smoothly-muscled, elegant dog of medium size with a short coat." And from the DPCA: "The appearance is that of a dog of medium size, with a body that is square." From a website on judging Dobermans: "Medium size and compactly built. This is a fundamental breed characteristic. The Doberman does not have a size disqualification, but to maintain a medium size dog, with the correct bone, substance and muscle we have a top of 28” for dogs and 26” for bitches. The Doberman must also be built for speed and should not be heavy or cumbersome. Neither should they be refined and spindly." See the repeated "medium"?
Jess is there a difference in the breed standard in the NA Dobie and the Euro Dobie? Just wondering about the hight etc.
 
There is no universal measurement that qualifies as "large" or "giant". However this is from the AKC's description of the Doberman: "A square, medium-sized dog, the Doberman Pinscher is muscular and possesses great endurance and speed." And from UKC "The Doberman Pinscher is a square-bodied, smoothly-muscled, elegant dog of medium size with a short coat." And from the DPCA: "The appearance is that of a dog of medium size, with a body that is square." From a website on judging Dobermans: "Medium size and compactly built. This is a fundamental breed characteristic. The Doberman does not have a size disqualification, but to maintain a medium size dog, with the correct bone, substance and muscle we have a top of 28” for dogs and 26” for bitches. The Doberman must also be built for speed and should not be heavy or cumbersome. Neither should they be refined and spindly." See the repeated "medium"?

The differences between European standard and NA standard is noticeable....
medium size dog compared to what? is a boxer a medium size dog or a GSD, or a Dutchie, or a Chesapeake bay Retriever? or a Golden retriever? are these medium sized dogs in your view? because they are not medium sized dogs... relevant to the term.. Medium.. being mid range or mid size... a Doberman male at 28" tall and 85-90lbs? is a MEDIUM Size dog? whose kidding who here?
compared to a Visla or a springer spaniel, or a brittany spaniel, or a German short haired pointer?
My 11 yr old dog is a medium size dog who is 50 lbs.... medium size is a very vague term...
the Doberman we see today and have seen since I first had one in 1974.... is a large dog... with large bones and muscular body and the weights vary from 65-95 lbs... 95 lbs is NOT a MEDIUM size dog by ANYONE standards... nor is a 85 lb dog.... or even a 75 lb dog... this is a large dog and a giant breed is over 120 lbs...
so regardless of how archaic and irrelevant the terminology is....
75-95 lbs is NOT A MEDIUM size dog... so give it a rest, will ya? I have medium sized dogs and my dobermans are not in that category.... no matter who you are.... a large breed dog size starts at 70+ lbs.... and a medium size dog size stops at around 60lbs.... so medium large? or just large... re articulate the standard... its archaic and misnomered for ages....
the terms are not relevant to the size of the current dog we know as a Doberman...
 

Back
Top