There was some insinuation or at least it 'read' as insinuation and that was why I posted the current posts. Just so we are all clear about our ideas of healthy and overweight and thin and lean etc....
a thin puppy is just as at risk as a 'heavy' puppy for issues related to insufficient nutrition... in the case of most puppies, it is a question of too thin and not to heavy.
Having had Neapolitan mastiffs for over 20 years in addition to Dobermans and Rotties, large breeds run the gamut of size and some mastiff puppies are under weight and most assuredly they can also be over weight but the former is more often the case rather than the latter. The same holds true for Dobie pups...
I see far to many underweight juveniles and young adults than I see overweight ones and I worry more about insufficient nutrition related issues than 'obesity' related issues in this breed.
I see the same problem in Malinois. GSD's, Dutchies, Rotties etc and other working breeds.
I hear people speak or talk about their puppy and are hyper concerned about their 'working dog' being too heavy and simply do not realize that puppies grow so fast at this stage that insufficient caloric intake is far the worse offense...
So, keeping them under weight is
not beneficial... as juveniles and young adults... until such time that your dogs are working daily and in competitions regularly and in constant intense training and then you see that you cannot keep weight on, that is a different story than a simple pet puppy growing up in a home that may work them
some day and yet you are keeping them 'thin' for their health
before they have matured is a far more detrimental condition. UNDER weight is worse.... than over weight..
Over weight by a few pounds can be worked off in a day or two or a week of growth... under weight by a few pounds is seriously jeopardizing their health especially when they are growing at the rates of 4-5 lbs a week as some of these puppies are and what they SHOULD Be gaining for their size.
Just making clear distinctions here between healthy and obsessive about 'thinness' and or 'leanness' in your 'working breed' puppy.
