• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Dog behavior/How to work on pack structure

That video is awesome. :) I think River is going to end up ruling the roost once she is bigger!!! :p Spock is most definitely in trouble!
 
Oh I know..........believe me....Hunter was a screamer. Schaudeh
is a screamer believe it or not when she is really really happy
Good Lord when she gets excited she screams sounds like you
are really hurting her or something. My German Shepherd
was a screamer, when my mom came to visit Mateese would
get so excited and start that screaming, I had to tell the neighbor
at the time when he heard that I WAS NOT HURTING HER,
she also would do that when she was going in the car........

MOTHERHOOD IS TOUGH REALLY TOUGH
 
I think you are right in telling him to back off. He sure likes to do those sucker punches to her doesn't he? I noticed that's usually when she yelped at him when he was getting too rough with the paws. I've never had to manage a puppy with a large dog so I could be off, but maybe wait until she gets bigger for the rough housing and only allow it occasionally on your terms.
 
I've never had to manage a puppy with a large dog so I could be off, but maybe wait until she gets bigger for the rough housing and only allow it occasionally on your terms.
That's what I"m trying to do. Normally I don't let it get to the point of that last video. I was just trying to show how rough it could get. It just doesn't seem okay to let it get to the point of her screaming. Late night is worst. The last hour before bed he gets really rough and refuses to listen to me. He and I had a come to Jesus talk 5 min ago and he got put to bed. He just would not back off and leave her alone. I was tired of it and went to put him to bed. He ran from me and when I went to grab his collar he threatened to bite. Not okay. So we had a moment and then he went to bed without his cookie.
 
What you are seeing is absolutely normal dog behavior, spock is playing with her and she is playing back, he also during this play is asserting his higher pack status, by standing over her, putting his head over her back, and attempting to pin her down. She is in turn being playful and when she yelps, it isnt so much that he is hurting her, but is more of a protest, as in HEY GET OFF ME YOU BIG DUFUS!!! She doesnt like it when its so rough as she feels overly dominated and gets a little scared, and that is the yelp you hear, its much more fear than pain. I would suggest a few things here, I know your raising her for sport as well as family, so I would not allow him to dominate her or break down her confidence in any way, and also you want to protect her, as he might not mean to, but could accidentally get over zealous and possibly hurt her, or cause her to get mad and fight back, thus creating a rift between them. If this were me, I would limit their time togethor, and would definately not have toys around for them to play with on their own terms, I would supervise their play times togethor, and then I would spend time playing with them seperately, as you dont want her to bond with him more than with you. Also as I said before, I would not have toys out for them to play with on their terms, the only time toys would come out, is when they were playing with me. This builds a strong bond with you, and also teaches them that the fun and rewards come from YOU, and no where else, therefore when you take that over to the training field, they learn that you are the center of the universe and all great things come from YOU, and they want to work for YOU.

Just some thoughts.
 
I would suggest a few things here, I know your raising her for sport as well as family, so I would not allow him to dominate her or break down her confidence in any way, and also you want to protect her, as he might not mean to, but could accidentally get over zealous and possibly hurt her, or cause her to get mad and fight back, thus creating a rift between them. If this were me, I would limit their time togethor, and would definately not have toys around for them to play with on their own terms, I would supervise their play times togethor, and then I would spend time playing with them seperately, as you dont want her to bond with him more than with you. Also as I said before, I would not have toys out for them to play with on their terms, the only time toys would come out, is when they were playing with me. This builds a strong bond with you, and also teaches them that the fun and rewards come from YOU, and no where else, therefore when you take that over to the training field, they learn that you are the center of the universe and all great things come from YOU, and they want to work for YOU.

Just some thoughts.
Thank you for the input Dale. It is hard to find that middle ground. I want them to be able to be a family and have a little bond to each other but I know she needs to bond more to me. It would be so much easier to give them each their own time if John wasn't out of town. She and I have time alone in the morning when Spock is still asleep and when he's napping. And he and I have time alone when she is napping. They actually only play for maybe 3 - 4 hours throughout the day and ALWAYS with me right there. I'm still trying to find out the best schedule for everyone. Its only been 72 hours afterall. I set myself for some difficulty in raising Spock how we did. He's never really been required to spend time quietly in his crate except when we eat or leave for short periods. So its hard to separate them when it isn't nap time. I guess now is as good a time as any to start working with him on that. If they don't have toys won't they only have wrestling as an option?
 
I really think Dale gave you some excellent advice. I
pretty much did the same with Schaudeh and Hunter
while he was so young because like I said before she
is a rough neck. Schaudeh was always the leader
Hunter was extremely gentle, as he grew up sometimes
while Schaudeh was laying on the floor he would stand
over her a little dominance there I would say on his
part but she still was always the leader.



 
Thank you for the input Dale. It is hard to find that middle ground. I want them to be able to be a family and have a little bond to each other but I know she needs to bond more to me. It would be so much easier to give them each their own time if John wasn't out of town. She and I have time alone in the morning when Spock is still asleep and when he's napping. And he and I have time alone when she is napping. They actually only play for maybe 3 - 4 hours throughout the day and ALWAYS with me right there. I'm still trying to find out the best schedule for everyone. Its only been 72 hours afterall. I set myself for some difficulty in raising Spock how we did. He's never really been required to spend time quietly in his crate except when we eat or leave for short periods. So its hard to separate them when it isn't nap time. I guess now is as good a time as any to start working with him on that. If they don't have toys won't they only have wrestling as an option?

You can have them togethor much more later on when she is a bit bigger and has already gone through the bonding process with you, and bonded to YOU. Otherwise, you will have a dog that is more interested in playing with the other dog than with you. then your in for a very hard life lesson, when you try to start training her and working her. I would say again, they dont need to be togethor much right now, teach him to be in the crate and her to do the same, that way you have more control in when they play etc etc.
As for no toys and wrestling, again, that is under your control, and what you have to realize, is that if you watch them, most of the wrestling and bitey face, was over who was going to have the toy, which is again, a pack heiarchy thing. So if you take the toy out of the equation, you have a much easier time controlling the situation, and again, you can use this to make it so YOU are her entire world, the center of her universe, and that ALL good fun things come from you.
 
I'll work on more crate time for both and Spock will be going to daycare tomorrow and Thursday this week and probably a couple days next week so I can focus on her and on my school work. It is just very hard to find that balance between sport and family with this. I realize that I need to separate them more right now for the bonding, I really truly do. But it is easier said than done in our situation. I can only do my best. They will be taught to spend some time in the crate alone. Spock already goes in there for quiet non-nap time when we eat lunch and dinner. But they are pets and part of the family, more than just sport dogs, and I don't want them spending hours in the crate.

Yes, the wrestling was over the toy but the attitude earlier in the day was all in fun. It wasn't till later in the day that they became more serious about it. That is when I should have taken the toys. There were two toys out and earlier in the day the game was more swapping toy to toy over and over. All in fun. Later they focused on one toy and it became more serious. I'll try taking the toys away and see what happens.

I'm sorry if this comes across defensive or ungrateful. I really appreciate all the advice and opinions. I wouldn't have posted here if I didn't want them. I'm just tired and frustrated so I'm not expressing or receiving well right now. I'm a perfectionist in a lot of ways and I love my dogs so I want to do right by them as much as possible. Its just so hard to make it all fit our situation sometimes.
 
I will also concur with those who stated that 'letting them work it out with the caveat of food or treat's' since this is how dogs learn to communicate with one another. If you ever go to a dog park and see owners who intervene on everything their dog does around other dogs, you will notice an introverted, shy, fearful dog. One who does not trust itself to read another dogs signals. If you let them sort out whats too rough, whats too much, then they learn how to read each other.
Personally I only intervene when I see that Gemma gets herself totally wound up and 'amped out' to the point where she just basically is a kid on too much cake and ice cream.... just 'cracked out' and runs herself silly and of course she hurts the baby dog because she has lost her own sense of balance. So I just call a time out and put her on a down stay and pull the baby over to me to my feet where I also make him lay down and just pet and calm them down. I will then get up and walk into the house where I let the puppy in for some 'alone time' and give Gemma a half hour to decompress from her 'hieghtened level of activity'.
I really think that those who try to be the referee and or coach for their dogs, ends up disconecting the dog from its own ability to read another of its own kind. Pack is a big deal for dogs and when you have more than one, you must let them establish for themselves by over seeing and not refereeing.. If too much energy is going on, a command or a simple non corrective movement to a place where you can separate them, just tones down the energy. I do like Cesar Milan alot and since the man has over 40 dogs in one confined area, you know that he lets them sort most things out unless there is negative or overly dominant energy that supercedes his own.
Dogs are not people, and they do not think like we think nor do they assign emotions with a judgment attached to them to the behaviors of their pack mates. They just accept the roles they feel naturally drawn too and we are there to just make sure that no one "puts an eye out".... or 'runs with scissors" is all... :)
 
I agree with some of what Dale says but not all....
I am not one to restrict what they play with unless it causes 'resource aggression"... I think if they are doing the level of play that I saw in that video? no one is going to get hurt. She is going to learn to avoid his feet, she is also going to learn to keep on her feet, he is going to learn what makes her yelp and how far he can push her.
I do agree with keeping the time they spend together for the first couple months to more time spent with you than just with Spock. She is quite young... so I kept Saava in the kitchen with Gemma outside and I left Saava with a boat load of things to chew on, boxes, toys, bottles, sqeakies, chewy things....
I think that they need to learn how to spend time alone and self entertain: boxes with paper make a great fort and a fabulously fun thing to play in, and a huge mess to clean up, but its all clean fun.. I also think that a baby gated area to keep her in for the hours when spock is outside or crated or kept in his area and then time spent together is when you are around and can basically just keep it from escalating into a bathroom brawl and or bodily damage.. if they are barking incessantly or doing destructive things, you gotta intervene, but aside from what might actually damage something or someone, I would just let them do their thing. Nothing I saw of what they were doing was anywhere near as rowdy as mine get. I have raised 2 litters of Neapolitan Mastiffs and always had 2 or three in the house, 2 litters or Rotties and always had two or three in the house and two litters of Dobermanns and likewise always had 2 or 3 sometimes 4 very large dogs in teh house. Never had blood drawn, never had any real brawls except for my two adult Neapolitans (my female was a total bitch to my male) and twice he had to seriously pin her to the floor with his whole body and it was a very scary thing to watch.. but they worked it out as he was neutered at 11 months old... these fights occurred when he was about 3-5 years old! so in all that time I have never had any of my dogs seriously or even sorta injure the other.... sans the aforementioned two and they died at 10 and 12 and never put the other one in stitches or the vets office and she hated him!
 
Nice video, Jess and it was interesting to see them interact. I think some of Dales advice was good too. I can certainly understand where he's coming from with the bonding and such. I even worried about that a bit with my two. That is an issue of them bonding to each other instead of the owner when you have more than one. It made me think I'd better start being more fun than Buddy! LOL

Buddy and Kali will play like yours and sometimes Buddy gets to where I feel the need to 'slow it down' a bit too. The funny thing is the few times that he has actually made her yip, he backs off immediately! Of course, I think it's associated with me acting like this :rp: . :rolleyes:
 
I am sure you don't let them play non-stop. River would get too tired. She needs a lot of sleep.
It should not be any problems if you let them play for 15- 20 min and then lock her in the crate for sleep/rest time.
That's a good idea to send Spock to the daycare. She needs to learn to be on her own.

Spock knows you for over 2 years and you are his boss... there is not a chance he will bond to River more than he is bonded to you.
Personally I never had this problem. Gino and Asha play together in the morning/afternoon for approx. 30 min. They have more play sessions in the evening. When nobody around Asha is locked in her crate. Yes you have to control how much they play together.
They need their own time... they will get tired of each other. Let them figure it out!

"If you ever go to a dog park and see owners who intervene on everything their dog does around other dogs, you will notice an introverted, shy, fearful dog." - I totally agree with Denissov. Correcting Spock too much may cause some issues in the future.

You can not train them together. When Pat is away there are not many options for you.... but when he is back Spock will spend more time with him and you will train River.

Stop analyzing it too much.... just let it be :)
 
http://leerburg.com/dogtrainingpodcasts.htm

Free Podcasts from Leerburg and there are dozens of them on puppy training and one on introducing new dogs to homes with dogs in them....
there are also free videos on what to do with working puppies and how to deal with them. This is probably one of the best resources for really grounded, solid information for dogs with a temperment like a Doberman. Ed Frawley has been raising Malinios's and GSD's and Dutchies for a very long time... like 40 years...
great info here! :glasses::pa:
 
I just wanted to clarify a few things.
I am giving training advice on what is going on right now, with river being a puppy, hence, the need to create a bond with jess and her, versus her and Spock, I am talking about the puppy here not Spock. Puppies go through a bonding phase, just as older dogs introduced to a new owner etc, do. And during this phase, if they spend most of their time with another dog, they will bond with that dog more so than the owner, this is simple dog psychology.
And as for the toys, I am only saying that as a for now thing, not permanently, but for now to be used as a tool for jess to create an even stronger bond with the puppy. I am giving advice on having sport dogs that are also family dogs or vice versa, after all, all of my dogs live in our home, and have free run of the house, yet are also working dogs, as this is how I believe it should be.
Hope that clarifies some things.
And don't worry Jess, you will be fine. :)
 
I tend to lean towards Lisa and Susie on this one, but I totally understand what Dale is saying if you are planning on developing a working dog. I guess it's finding the balance that you, Jess, are questioning. As Lisa said, it will be a lot easier when Pat is back.

I think you did a great job on the video and I agree with Dale that she was yelping more out of fear or "that is too much" than because she is actually hurt. This will also teach Spock when to back off. :)

Your doing great, Jess. And OMG they are so cute. Spock is just dying to play with her. It's going to be a lot of fun when she gets bigger and they can really go at it!
 
Thank you all. I feel a bit better after some sleep but I still stress about it. I just know that this is such a crucial time that I need to get right. I need to figure out a way to block them off from each other more. Its looking more and more like the only real way to do this is make poor Spock spend more time in his crate. I hate doing that to him but I don't know what else to do. River will have some crate time, too. She needs to learn to be quiet and alone. As it is she carries on when in the crate if not asleep and poor Spock can't stand it. He comes to me looking all worried and won't play as long as she's fussing. I didn't take Spock to daycare today but will tomorrow and Friday. I'm thinking 2 - 3 days a week would be a good amount for him for the next couple weeks and that might continue for a couple more months if need be. Right now this is the schedule we're falling into, it varies a bit of course:
0630 - River wakes up and needs to go out. She does her potty and we play in the living room just the two of us for 1 to 1 1/2 hours.
0730 or 0800 - River goes down for a nap and I either get school work done or get some more sleep myself
0930 - River wakes up and goes out. Then Spock gets up and goes out. They do end up out there at the same time but luckily he's just mature enough to wander off to do his business before trying to play. This gives her time to do hers and he's told to leave it if he comes over before she is done.
0945 - Breakfast. River is put in her "pen" and Spock is served first. She is not let back out until he is done eating and she is quiet. She has a bone in there in case she gets done faster. We're working on her learning to be quiet and alone.
1000 - They play, supervised in the living room and outside.
1130 - River goes down for a nap. Spock has time with me but is usually tired and naps himself.
1300 - River wakes up, goes out, and has lunch.
1330 - She and Spock play for a little while, supervised in the living room and outside.
1500 - River and Spock both go down for a nap.
1600 - River gets up and goes out to do her business. We play while Spock sleeps (or whines)
1730 - River goes down for a nap, Spock gets up. He and I have our time and go for a walk and cuddle.
1830 - Dinner for both
1900 - River and Spock play for a little while, supervised in the living room (too dark for much outside)
2000 - River naps, Spock and I have time for him
2100 - Last hour before bed. They play some in the living room. This is usually when Spock gets really wound up and gets in the most trouble.
2200 - Bedtime.

I just wanted to clarify a few things.
I am giving training advice on what is going on right now, with river being a puppy, hence, the need to create a bond with jess and her, versus her and Spock, I am talking about the puppy here not Spock. Puppies go through a bonding phase, just as older dogs I produced to a new owner etc, do. And during this phase, if they spend most of their time with another dog, they will bond with that dog more so than the owner, this is simple dog psychology.
And as for the toys, I am only saying that as a for now thing, not permanently, but for now to be used as a tool for jess to create an even stronger bond with the puppy. I am giving advice on having sport dogs that are also family dogs or vice versa, after all, all of my dogs live in our home, and have free run of the house, yet are also working dogs, as this is how I believe it should be.
Hope that clarifies some things.
And don't worry Jess, you will be fine. :)
Thanks Dale. Its funny, right now Spock is the one more fascinated with her. He follows her everywhere and only sometimes will she follow him. She runs to me for attention and to save her from the big meanie. I tried taking the toys away and they just focused more on each other. Then found other things to wrestle over like the bed or me. That family/sport balance is why I wanted your advice on this Dale.

Seriously, thank you all for your input and help on this. Its just all so new and confusing to me.
 
I tend to lean towards Lisa and Susie on this one, but I totally understand what Dale is saying if you are planning on developing a working dog. I guess it's finding the balance that you, Jess, are questioning. As Lisa said, it will be a lot easier when Pat is back.
It is that elusive balance that I'm not sure how to achieve without making poor Spock "suffer" for it. I hate to do that to him. Of all the freakin' times for the Marines to decide to send Pat away for 2 weeks it just had to be now.
 

Back
Top