• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Dog behavior/How to work on pack structure

Marinegeekswife

Hot Topics Subscriber
As you all know, this is our first experience with two dogs in the house. I know we should work to put Spock above River in the pack structure but there are some things I'm confused about. I'm sure I'm just over thinking it but I so want to get this right. Here are a couple scenarios, what would you guys suggest?

Whenever River wakes up in the morning or from her naps, if Spock is also asleep he wakes up and whines to get out. This results in a very sleepy, very bratty Spock by the end of the day because he isn't sleeping as long at night (normally 12 hours but he's only getting about 8 with her) and his nap is short, too (normally 3 hours in the afternoon and maybe 45 when we eat dinner but he's only getting an hour a couple times a day with her here). Should I just ignore him and make him sleep even if she's up? Would this be putting her ahead of him?

He takes a toy from her. I let him have it for a couple minutes and then take it from him, hold it for a few seconds, and then give it to her. I don't allow him to take it back right away and only allow it after a few minutes if he is gentle about it. Is that putting her before him? Or by me taking it does that just put me ahead of both?

She takes a toy from him. He tries to take it back roughly so I tell him "no" and "easy". By allowing her to keep it for a while (just until he's easy about it...can take some time) am I allowing her the higher position?

In the end, aren't we simply referees while they figure it all out? At what point (other than just when she's bigger/stronger) do you more or less let them figure it out?
 
I'm not so sure that you want to exactly give Spock a higher pack ranking... He obviously is allowed more privledges since he is older and trained, but in the end they are both "the dogs". While River is just a little puppy, it's your job to control her if you don't want Spock to discipline her himself (bad idea). You control the areas of the house she has access to, her meals, when she's taken out, how far she can go in being a pest, where she sleeps... everything. Spock will see that he has more privledges and that you are the one in charge of the puppy and her discipline. If you demand that the dogs respect eachother by stepping in when either River is being too much of a pest or Spock is playing a little too rough then they can both have the same status in the house and you can maintain a position of leadership. With your supervision, they will learn how to live together in peace.

I didn't allow Hans and Ladybug to play with toys when Hans was little since she has a bad DA streak. When we do play with toys, each dog has its own and usually an extra. (Two dogs, three balls) and I try to be the most interesting thing about the games. So I can't really comment on the toy scenarios... But Spock is really missing some sleep huh? LOL He must have gotten spoiled with all the sleep he got when you were away and Pat was working ;) I bet he will get used to the new level of activity around the house :)
 
I'm not so sure that you want to exactly give Spock a higher pack ranking... He obviously is allowed more privledges since he is older and trained, but in the end they are both "the dogs". While River is just a little puppy, it's your job to control her if you don't want Spock to discipline her himself (bad idea). You control the areas of the house she has access to, her meals, when she's taken out, how far she can go in being a pest, where she sleeps... everything. Spock will see that he has more privledges and that you are the one in charge of the puppy and her discipline. If you demand that the dogs respect eachother by stepping in when either River is being too much of a pest or Spock is playing a little too rough then they can both have the same status in the house and you can maintain a position of leadership. With your supervision, they will learn how to live together in peace.
I agree with the above. I think others with two large dogs can speak better about this but what Ingrid said is about how it is here with Buddy and Kali. I step in just like she said. I will 'let' them 'fight' over toys just because it's not really a fight ....it will usually end up in a game of tug. :D The only thing I try and step in for is when Buddy has a bone and she wants it. There are about 25 bones around here and she wants the one he has. :nono: There were times that she would lay in front of him and whine while he's chewing. I would step in then. It's HIS bone, HE had it first, now go find another! (mom mode! :p) It's never the other way around. Buddy doesn't seem to want the bones much unless it's a fresh one, but since Kali's been here, they've resurrected a few more! But he does relinquish it to her when he grows tired of it and she grabs it like she won! lol

As for the sleeping, I find that kinda funny! I mean, I always thought dogs slept a lot or that they can catch "cat naps" (dog naps? :scratch: ) throughout the day and never thought of them as crabby from lack of sleep. She must be really keeping him up!! LOL Poor Spock, he's like a new dad! lol
 
in my house there is a definite pack order.I am top human..........and my boy zoo is top dog.followed by rox and bottom is chance........when I brought my pup home zoo saw that it was my puppy and instantly took over a parent roll.......... the other 2 just stayed as far away from the pup as they could lol! if the pup snuck up on them they took off.....it was as if they knew she was not to be messed with lol! now they play a bit with her but always look to me for approval.
for toys.....A-la and I play together......... alone with toys. the big dogs have a few rope tugs in the yard. they will not play with A-la. if she goes for the tug they drop it. no questions asked..............except zoo.......... if he has the toy nobody even trys to take it lol!.
 
Our trainer told me that we have to trust our dogs and let them work it out on their own since if we step in it can sometimes intensify things and interfere with their natural way of working things out in the pack order. Of course she said trust them, but always be there to step in if you "have" to.
This only applies to their own actions when they're interacting between themselves, and if we want to do something with them, we of course call the shots.
Even if I pay attention when they're going at it I can see that they get a little more intense, but if I just keep going about my business and let them do their thing it levels off much faster. Of course that doesn't mean I don't have them in my vision out of the corner of my eye though. LOL
I know how you feel about worrying while the pup is so darn little, but as long as your older dog isn't DA I think they naturally know how far they can go without hurting them.

As for the sleeping, it is an adjustment period right now for both dogs, and once you get a routine settled Spock will go back to getting the amount of sleep he needs. ;)
 
They must have heard me posting! lol
IMG_0281 [1024x768].webp
This was just a while ago. She lays and watches, quietly. Buddy is not intimidated but I never allow anything to escalate beyond this. After I snapped a few pics, Kali started the whine. I corrected. Her first, but I did a slight Cesar 'finger point' at Buddy too just as a reminder that he is to keep his cool too. It took about three corrections at Kali to stop whining so don't think it was immediate. ;) About 10 minutes after that, Buddy walked away from it and Kali went in for the kill. :D
 
Well, you don't want to full on Elizabeth Marshall Thomas (The Hidden life of Dogs, the Social Life of Dogs), but I'd say that to a degree, they can sort themselves out. I think you're right to correct River if she gets too obnoxious, and Spock if he gets too rough. I guess maybe "mutual respect" is a good goal, since ultimately, the humans are the ones in charge and the decision makers? I've only ever had the Elka, so I have no firsthand experience on pack stuff (though notice, it didn't keep me from putting in my two cents!)
 
I let mine work it out. The only times I intervene for instance is something such as Java chewing a bone and Paige will eventually take it, even if there are two(lol). I will take the bone from Paige, replace it with her own toy and give it back to Java. The other situation I'll intervene is when things are getting a bit too rough or sometimes after wrestling they'll start posturing, I'll send them to their "spots" then, to separate them. When I brought Paige home, I never worried about making one dog over the other dog in the pack structure. Java was top dog, but they worked it out and now Paige is top dog in the end. She'll let Java think she's top dog out on walks. :p
 
Thank you all for the input. I knew I had to be overthinking it. I'll let them figure it out and just play referee. The only time I'm not comfortable with is the bones. After Spock's posturing the first night I just want to keep those private, maybe for crate time only. She doesn't seem to care which bone she gets as long as she gets one. Spock is the one that will stare her down while she eats one and won't take the one I set aside for him. He just wants what she has. I even gave him a brand new one just for him. He chewed it for a bit then either got all he wanted or realized she had one of his old ones (probably should have just started out new all around). l took him outside and showed him where he left his new one twice. Even told him to pick it up and bring it inside. He just left it to come in and stare at her while drooling. *Sigh* I'll get it figured out.
 
I totally agree with they will work it out. When I got Hunter
I just sort of let them work it out, the only time I did anything
is when Schaudeh got a little too rough, she is a rough neck and
that is the only time..........They worked it out and she mothered
him, they were the very best of friends. It all ended up very very
well and they were inseparable they set their own place.



 
I didn't allow Hans and Ladybug to play with toys when Hans was little since she has a bad DA streak. When we do play with toys, each dog has its own and usually an extra. (Two dogs, three balls) and I try to be the most interesting thing about the games. So I can't really comment on the toy scenarios... But Spock is really missing some sleep huh? LOL He must have gotten spoiled with all the sleep he got when you were away and Pat was working ;) I bet he will get used to the new level of activity around the house :)

How do you manage it? No matter how many toys in the house or sticks in the backyard they want to get from each other.

She doesn't seem to care which bone she gets as long as she gets one. Spock is the one that will stare her down while she eats one and won't take the one I set aside for him. He just wants what she has. I even gave him a brand new one just for him. He chewed it for a bit then either got all he wanted or realized she had one of his old ones (probably should have just started out new all around). l took him outside and showed him where he left his new one twice. Even told him to pick it up and bring it inside. He just left it to come in and stare at her while drooling. *Sigh* I'll get it figured out.

That's what happens in our house but in the reverse order. Asha behaves like Spock.

I agree with others. You can not establish the pack order. They will figure it out.
You are the leader and you should be able to correct them and stop the game anytime if you find it too wild.
 
I agree with Jan, Amanda and Dale. We had a 10 year old calm assertive Golden when we got Bailey. We trusted her 100% that she would not do anything wrong when it came to the puppy. She did on occasion roll on her head when she was very little, but Bailey never got damaged from it. LOL. They are dogs and we are humans. Inevitable they know better than us and just like Dale said we can't make a dog top in the hierarchy. As long as the energy doesn't become aggressive I would let them sort it out on their own. You want to be careful that you don't let her get away with everything just because she is little and Spock isn't allowed to show her the boundries. Think about what the mom would do if they were still with her. She sure as hell doesn't take any crap from them. :)
 
I agree with Jan, Amanda and Dale. We had a 10 year old calm assertive Golden when we got Bailey. We trusted her 100% that she would not do anything wrong when it came to the puppy. She did on occasion roll on her head when she was very little, but Bailey never got damaged from it. LOL. They are dogs and we are humans. Inevitable they know better than us and just like Dale said we can't make a dog top in the hierarchy. As long as the energy doesn't become aggressive I would let them sort it out on their own. You want to be careful that you don't let her get away with everything just because she is little and Spock isn't allowed to show her the boundries. Think about what the mom would do if they were still with her. She sure as hell doesn't take any crap from them. :)
Boy you have that right Katja, the mom will take them down and grab the pups
and sometimes they will even yip, I agree with the energy thing not turning
to aggression too.

This is getting off the track but...........with Schaudeh when she was
young and I was training her and she was a PISTOL.....I had to take
her down just like the mom to let her know who was going to be
Alpha ...........and it was not going to be HER.
 
I agree with Jan, Amanda and Dale. We had a 10 year old calm assertive Golden when we got Bailey. We trusted her 100% that she would not do anything wrong when it came to the puppy. She did on occasion roll on her head when she was very little, but Bailey never got damaged from it. LOL. They are dogs and we are humans. Inevitable they know better than us and just like Dale said we can't make a dog top in the hierarchy. As long as the energy doesn't become aggressive I would let them sort it out on their own. You want to be careful that you don't let her get away with everything just because she is little and Spock isn't allowed to show her the boundries. Think about what the mom would do if they were still with her. She sure as hell doesn't take any crap from them. :)
I try not to let her get away with pestering him too much. Its just difficult when she doesn't know any commands yet. My biggest fear is him stepping on her and breaking one of her tiny bones. She's getting good about screaming like a banshee if he gets too rough or scares her. This usually results in him backing off because he knows he's done wrong. I just still worry about him getting too wound up at this point.
 
I try not to let her get away with pestering him too much. Its just difficult when she doesn't know any commands yet. My biggest fear is him stepping on her and breaking one of her tiny bones. She's getting good about screaming like a banshee if he gets too rough or scares her. This usually results in him backing off because he knows he's done wrong. I just still worry about him getting too wound up at this point.
She doesn't need to know any of our humans commands. Spock speaks 'dog' and so does she. He will be able to tell her when he has had enough of her pestering. Our Goldie would growl at Bailey if she wanted to steel a toy, but I knew 100% that she would never hurt her. She didn't have to because she was someone to respect and Bailey understood. However a month after we got Bailey our Goldie was diagnosed with Lymphoma and as she got sicker Bailey got bigger, stronger and more of a pain in the butt. It made a big difference in their interaction. I am sure if Fanny hadn't been weakened it would have been a very different and more pleasant scenario.

He's not going to hurt her. They are very hardy and don't get too worried when she screams. It is something puppies do to avoid getting hurt, not when they are getting hurt. It's like them saying "Don't hurt me, I'm just a baby". Bailey would cream bloody murder if a dog came running cup to her too fast and she would tuck her tail and cower. People would get very worried and thought that their dog had hurt her. I would tell them that she is just making sure they don't. :)

She will still do that occasionally and did it the other day with my friends dog. He is a big husky/white shepherd mix and his energy was a little too high for her liking, so she yelped. He wasn't even near her.
 
"I try not to let her get away with pestering him too much. Its just difficult when she doesn't know any commands yet"
LOL... you should not worry so much. She found the way to protect herself :) screaming helps.
Spock will have scars all over his neck. Take it as is. It doesn't hurt much and it will pass. He knows she is a puppy and he won't hurt her.
I didn't allow them play too long. It's tiring for a puppy. River should sleep up to 17 hours daily.

It will take time for Spock to adjust to his new life and schedule. Gino lost his appetite and was tired... but he is completely back to normal now and enjoys his playmates (sometimes ;))

My boy still gets new scars occasionally but not too many now. He fights when she gets out of control.
 
I try not to let her get away with pestering him too much. Its just difficult when she doesn't know any commands yet. My biggest fear is him stepping on her and breaking one of her tiny bones. She's getting good about screaming like a banshee if he gets too rough or scares her. This usually results in him backing off because he knows he's done wrong. I just still worry about him getting too wound up at this point.[/quote
That is totally understandable, I was the same way with Schaudeh and Hunter
he screamed too and she would know she did something wrong then she would
lay down and stare at him until he came back up to her. I don't blame you
for being cautious and not wanting an accident to happen, they really do
seem to know they are just a baby. The worries of MOTHERHOOD AND
FATHERHOOD.......................:);)
 
"I try not to let her get away with pestering him too much. Its just difficult when she doesn't know any commands yet"
LOL... you should not worry so much. She found the way to protect herself :) screaming helps.
Spock will have scars all over his neck. Take it as is. It doesn't hurt much and it will pass. He knows she is a puppy and he won't hurt her.
I didn't allow them play too long. It's tiring for a puppy. River should sleep up to 17 hours daily.

It will take time for Spock to adjust to his new life and schedule. Gino lost his appetite and was tired... but he is completely back to normal now and enjoys his playmates (sometimes ;))

My boy still gets new scars occasionally but not too many now. He fights when she gets out of control.
Bailey also has bite marks sometimes still. Easter can get a little over the top. I suspect it has to do with the days we don't get to go to the park and just play and exercise at home. Bailey will nick Easter sometimes as well, but usually it's the other way around. Them being litter mates makes it for more of a volatile relationship as they are more equal and will try for the top spot all the time.
 

Back
Top