• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Linus bit me..

Wonderful, I remember what I was like when that started happening to me.. uh oh.

Sorry LOL, but its how it is, been there done that. With Apollo is started with 7 month and he was a bit heavier then Linus is right now. Apollo is now 2 years and 4 month and weights around 90lbs of solid muscle :D
You will get through this believe me.
 
I also want to add that any dog can be dangerous in the right situation. This is one of my soap boxes about people and the dog park. ANY dog can bite someone. This does not make them "vicious". Many times when a dog bites we need to look at the situation that preceded the bite. Did a child run up to a strange dog or run around in general? Many large dogs do not understand that a child that is at eye level is a human but think they are possibly another dog to play with or to teach a lesson. Why is this different in a dog park? I have been verbally abused and told my dog should be killed because I politely asked some children (that should not have been in the dog park) to please not run and rough house with each other around my dog. People forget all the rules when in a dog park and place all in danger, dogs and humans by not respecting the dogs ability to cause harm.
My dogs are also rescues and though they have lived with me since they were 7 weeks old, someone cut off Billy's right ear before he was 3 days old. Some would say that he should not or does not remember that incident but, I disagree. Research shows that when humans or animals brains are in infancy the connections being made are crucial to wellbeing and trust. If great pain was caused to Billy when he did not even have his eyes open and he only could understand scent then he would conceivably associate that scent with bad things. Josie had her tail docked at the same time. Both of these dogs are skittish and easily frightened. Josie is still very social but Billy only likes certain strangers and really does not care to be pet by strangers. We work very hard on "leave-it" which I use for all manner of things I don't want Billy to do; chase kids, bikes, other dogs, etc. With patience, time, and consistency I have seen a vast improvement in Billy. I still watch him carefully and control his surroundings. We quietly leave the dog park if he becomes too aroused to listen to me and I am very careful to not respond with yelling or running as this will only escalate a situation.

Again, just my opinion and I don't mean to offend.
 
Again, just my opinion and I don't mean to offend.

Nothing you said would offend anyone. Simply giving advice and I appreciate it. If I was afraid of being offended, I shouldn't be on a forum :) Or maybe even the internet!

I think it's going to take a lot more time with Linus, we just spent a good 25 minutes outside learning stay. He got bored quickly, but was always rewarded with treats when he came or sat and stayed for any length of time. I was able to make it to the other side of my yard before he came running to me, which is great! But still going to take lots of time.

But like everyone keeps saying, I have to just keep spending time on training him, but it's very discouraging when you don't see it going anywhere... Which is why I decided to attend obedience classes with him. Because OBVIOUSLY I'm doing something wrong.

You will get through this believe me.
I can only hope!!!
 
You are not doing anything wrong! Dobermans are challenging and like I said, not at their best at Linus's age. I've been there when it seems like nothing you say makes any dent into their thick skulls! One other bit of advice; make your training sessions shorter but, more frequent. Young dogs, like children, have a short attention span. training should be like a game and everyone has fun, gets treats, yay!!
 
All i can say is you must be on top of this NOW , no more humming and harrying you are the boss no if's or but's i just cannot imagine my dog acting this way at any age , he knows your weakness's and is pushing you and you must not tolerate it full stop, trainers are great but they cannot be there 24/7 , i would just have kept giving him the rock a 100 times and taken it out of his mouth a 100 times until he realises this is it, this is what is going to happen, so i might as well give it up, i can tell you now no way would Bella be showing her teeth or biting , my friend lost her Doberman at Christmas as she had swallowed a stone and had got stuck she was only five and had an agonising death , this is not a game it is life or death , please take two steps up and be the teacher you should be to this adolescent Boy.
If i seem a bit harsh it is only because i care , Linus needs a leader not a follower , prove your family wrong and show them that Dobes are the best dogs in the world ;)
 
It took Mysti a very short time to learn sit, down and come, but it took her forever to learn heel and stay! I thought she would never learn them. I had plans for her and she was not conforming to my timetable. She had to pass her therapy dog test at one year, and heel was a big one, so was a few other things she was stubborn about. It was not that she did not know how or could not learn them, it was she knew them and chose not to please me at the time. When she was 15 months old she passed her CGC and Therapy Dog test and still gave me a hard time with heel when we went on walks but when it came to the hospital she behaved like a dream.
Dobes are funny creatures who have very sharp minds. They know and they think! Its up to us to learn how is the best way to teach them and how to know when we are getting through to them. Its a challenge but it is well rewarded once our babies finally "get it" and behave as we teach them.
 
All i can say is you must be on top of this NOW , no more humming and harrying you are the boss no if's or but's i just cannot imagine my dog acting this way at any age , he knows your weakness's and is pushing you and you must not tolerate it full stop, trainers are great but they cannot be there 24/7 , i would just have kept giving him the rock a 100 times and taken it out of his mouth a 100 times until he realises this is it, this is what is going to happen, so i might as well give it up, i can tell you now no way would Bella be showing her teeth or biting , my friend lost her Doberman at Christmas as she had swallowed a stone and had got stuck she was only five and had an agonising death , this is not a game it is life or death , please take two steps up and be the teacher you should be to this adolescent Boy.
If i seem a bit harsh it is only because i care , Linus needs a leader not a follower , prove your family wrong and show them that Dobes are the best dogs in the world ;)

This was being typed as mine was also, and I just want to say this ... after 5 days ... 5 agonizing days in the hospital with Nexus, this cannot be stressed enough. Obstructions are critical, often fatal. Make Linus learn to give up what he has in his mouth! If he doesnt learn it it will only hurt him.
In some cases, if all else fails, offer something of more value than what he has, but the first step is to teach him to give you whatever he has, no matter what.
If I had been able to teach Nexus sooner what NOT to eat, I never would have had to go through those 5 days.
 
If i seem a bit harsh it is only because i care , Linus needs a leader not a follower , prove your family wrong and show them that Dobes are the best dogs in the world ;)

I care as well, and like I said earlier, if I couldn't handle harshness, I wouldn't be on the internet. I've been trying to show him I'm a leader and not his follower. I can see improvements from when I first got him, but he still has too many moments where he doesn't listen. This being one of them! I just need someone to actually watch what I'm doing and tell me what I'm doing wrong. He does know sit and lay and only gets on furniture when I say so and gets off, but like Starlight said, he's having an issue with stay and OBVIOUSLY with drop-it.

For instance, he's chewing on a bone right now. I took it from him, there was a quick growl and he noticed what he was doing was wrong. I gave it back, and took it back each time saying drop. I did this four times, and he only growled at me once. So, he's learning and is quickly catching himself. So there's some improvement.

Is it possible that maybe his history with his past family was so bad, that he developed these traits before I even got them? And now that he's becoming more comfortable with me, he's retorting to their traits because maybe he got what he wanted when he acted mean? Or is it me?
 
I don't think it's an obsession because it's the first time he's eaten a rock, and like I said, I think he swallowed it out of spite.

I really feel like I need to chime in and I hope I don't offend. First of all, I don't think dogs do things out of spite. Pica is a real problem for dogs and people. Pica is eating things we should not eat, like people eating starch. Billy eats socks. He has had 3 surgeries already for intestinal blockages. It sounds like Linus is just being a dobe and being a vacuum cleaner. Dobes are known for eating all manner of things they should not. I agree with the idea of trading for a higher value item. I think that making a huge deal out of it gives him attention and then by "putting him on the ground" confuses him. He thinks, why is my human protector acting like this, I'd better let him know that I don't understand this and I'm scared- the biting and growling. Linus is just a puppy and dobes don't really grow a brain for about 2 years. Until he can be trusted to not eat foreign bodies he will need to be watched like a 2 year old and crated when he cannot be watched. every time he picks up a rock make a game of offering a high value item, treat, toy, whatever Linus really likes. Try to limit his access to the rocks with x-pens, etc. Make sure he has lots and lots of exercise and work on basic training and "drop-it". Always offer a better treat than what he has picked up and lots of praise for being such a good, smart boy. With training, Linus will begin to understand the concept of drop-it and that he gets something better when he drops the item. Drop it is a critical command that all dogs should know and comply, especially when they may pick up dead things or other unsavory items that seem wonderful to a dog but are distasteful to humans. Josie has never really forgiven me from removing a part of a cat carcass from her mouth by force. I should have used the trade but was so disgusted by her holding a cat leg in her mouth I over reacted.

Remember, Dobermans are bred to be companions and protectors. Linus will be confused if the person he sees as his responsibility handles him roughly and pins him to the ground. I personally don't agree with that mode of dog training. Dogs are not wolves so don't really respond to that type of handling. Remember, Linus was trying to warn you that he was afraid by your actions, he does not want to bite you but, he probably felt that this was the only avenue left to him.

Pica is a real problem that can have fatal consequences. If Linus develops pica for rocks he can potentially die at the worst and will probably experience some pretty significant pain. On the positive side, he will most likely grow out of his rock eating. Exercise, exercise, exercise and lots of good chewing toys. I use raw buffalo bones I buy at the feed store or the Read Barn filled sterile bones, always with supervision, of course.

Good luck and I do not consider myself the expert, just talking from experience.

Thanks for listening.

Nexus has had 2 surgeries, and after the second we had to really get ahold of her problem. It involved never letting her be unsupervised. We had to do this at all times. I thought I had a new baby in the house. When she did get something she wasnt supposed to have, she didnt know the drop it perfectly at first, we worked diligently on her to try to teach her, but she saw it as a game of "make me" so we did the substitution for the higher value item, and she learned to drop it for something better. It was not until recently that she "graduated" to being able to be left alone for short periods of time without being caged, but with Bella having to be penned, we will put both together if it is longer than an hour or less.
Rocks can be very dangerous for a dog to eat as well. My husband's cousins dog ate one and he had a vet bill of almost $1000 to show for it. After Nexus's second incident where she ruptured after the obstruction, we had paid over $3000.
I am of a mind to think that the reasons for his behaviour are important, but of equal importance is the fact that he ate the rock and can not be let to do it again and so all advice is good advice, maybe it is a combination of alot of factors as to why he bit, it could be he was scared, he tried to be dominant and he bit. Whichever it is, I hope that you have success in finding and helping him to correct it so he can have a long healthy life. He is lucky to have a caring owner who wants to help him and dont worry if it seems to take too long, its not the length of the road but the goal at the end of it that matters.
 
I care as well, and like I said earlier, if I couldn't handle harshness, I wouldn't be on the internet. I've been trying to show him I'm a leader and not his follower. I can see improvements from when I first got him, but he still has too many moments where he doesn't listen. This being one of them! I just need someone to actually watch what I'm doing and tell me what I'm doing wrong. He does know sit and lay and only gets on furniture when I say so and gets off, but like Starlight said, he's having an issue with stay and OBVIOUSLY with drop-it.

For instance, he's chewing on a bone right now. I took it from him, there was a quick growl and he noticed what he was doing was wrong. I gave it back, and took it back each time saying drop. I did this four times, and he only growled at me once. So, he's learning and is quickly catching himself. So there's some improvement.

Is it possible that maybe his history with his past family was so bad, that he developed these traits before I even got them? And now that he's becoming more comfortable with me, he's retorting to their traits because maybe he got what he wanted when he acted mean? Or is it me?

You are right to take the bone from him with no hesitation , just do it over and over , repetition brings calmness they just accept it especially at this age ,he is still a baby , sit on the floor with him give him a biscuit and then take it out of his mouth this brings respect he will soon realise who's in charge as at the moment he thinks he is claiming the " in charge role " and you have to take it back , i realise that us who have had dogs and other animals all our lives do not have to think about these things as they come more natural , i also realise that this is more difficult for you as Linus is your first dog and first Dobe and you are working with all the advice that is given to you so well done :thumbsup: , he is only a lamb in Doberman's clothing you know, they are just big marshmallows inside :rolleyes:
 
I care as well, and like I said earlier, if I couldn't handle harshness, I wouldn't be on the internet. I've been trying to show him I'm a leader and not his follower. I can see improvements from when I first got him, but he still has too many moments where he doesn't listen. This being one of them! I just need someone to actually watch what I'm doing and tell me what I'm doing wrong. He does know sit and lay and only gets on furniture when I say so and gets off, but like Starlight said, he's having an issue with stay and OBVIOUSLY with drop-it.

For instance, he's chewing on a bone right now. I took it from him, there was a quick growl and he noticed what he was doing was wrong. I gave it back, and took it back each time saying drop. I did this four times, and he only growled at me once. So, he's learning and is quickly catching himself. So there's some improvement.

Is it possible that maybe his history with his past family was so bad, that he developed these traits before I even got them? And now that he's becoming more comfortable with me, he's retorting to their traits because maybe he got what he wanted when he acted mean? Or is it me?

Its not you, I am pretty sure he knows you love and care for him. I think it might be possible he is testing his limits maybe? like kids do? Just keep consistent, its key right now, and reinforce with love. Firm, but love :)
 
you need to make short session, maybe 10 minutes, then a lot of play and then later on another 10 minutes session, at this age, they need a lot of breaks. they can stay focused that long. Always end with a big fun thing , thats very important. Teach new things through the day and like i said don't make it to long, always take breaks in between and lot of preising for everything he does right. If he dosent do something right just ignore it and move on :)
 
So he had his bone, and I went to take it away, first time he growled a bit and let me take it. I made him sit and lay down again and I gave the bone back. Let him have it for a few seconds, and I took it away again. This time, he bit me AGAIN. He's getting VERY close to going back to the shelter. Judging by you guys, you guys haven't had this issue. It's not like I beat him at all, he just gets disciplined when he acts up, usually by removing him from the situation. But this biting is really getting scary...

I didn't use anything forceful, it was between his front two paws and he was looking at me. I went and touched it, and he bit me. So this time, it wasn't me scaring him. He knew I was standing there. It's this dominance thing... I don't feel this is normal for puppies to be THIS aggressive towards their owner.
 
So he had his bone, and I went to take it away, first time he growled a bit and let me take it. I made him sit and lay down again and I gave the bone back. Let him have it for a few seconds, and I took it away again. This time, he bit me AGAIN. He's getting VERY close to going back to the shelter. Judging by you guys, you guys haven't had this issue. It's not like I beat him at all, he just gets disciplined when he acts up, usually by removing him from the situation. But this biting is really getting scary...

I didn't use anything forceful, it was between his front two paws and he was looking at me. I went and touched it, and he bit me. So this time, it wasn't me scaring him. He knew I was standing there. It's this dominance thing... I don't feel this is normal for puppies to be THIS aggressive towards their owner.
I hate to say 'I told you so' but I told you so. The first bite and growl had nothing to do with him being scared. This dog does not respect you. He sees you as his follower and that is what happens to followers when they try to take something away from the leader. He warned you with a growl and any follower dog would have backed off, and if they didn't would have gotten bit, just like you did. If you do not get this issue under control NOW, Linus is going to get out of control and you will be unable to do anything to him. He may even bite you next time you try to put him in the crate. Every time something like this happens he gets more powerful and it will be more difficult for you to become the pack leader. A Dobie is very clever and not a beginners dog. As someone mentioned they will have you pegged in a second and push all your buttons. It so does not sound to me like he is scared of you what so ever. And dogs do not get their feelings hurt either. They are dogs and do not have human emotions.

He sounds like he is escalating. A pack leader can do ANYTHING to their dog. They may not like it (like nail clipping) but they sure as hell will not growl or bite.

Did you ever watch any Cesar Millan?
 
So he had his bone, and I went to take it away, first time he growled a bit and let me take it. I made him sit and lay down again and I gave the bone back. Let him have it for a few seconds, and I took it away again. This time, he bit me AGAIN. He's getting VERY close to going back to the shelter. Judging by you guys, you guys haven't had this issue. It's not like I beat him at all, he just gets disciplined when he acts up, usually by removing him from the situation. But this biting is really getting scary...

I didn't use anything forceful, it was between his front two paws and he was looking at me. I went and touched it, and he bit me. So this time, it wasn't me scaring him. He knew I was standing there. It's this dominance thing... I don't feel this is normal for puppies to be THIS aggressive towards their owner.

Dont give up on him please. I think the last thing he needs is for someone to send him away again. I had an issue with Mysti growling and snapping with food and occasionally toys. I got her so I could get to her food without too much trouble, but it took alot of patience, and there were a couple times when she was older that she reverted back to trying to growl at me over a toy. It is frustrating to no end, I know, but the worst thing I think you can do to him is to send him away. Is there anyone at all you can consult with, a trainer or behaviorist that can come in to help or a breeder that is close that might be able to help you with him?
 
I hate to say 'I told you so' but I told you so. The first bite and growl had nothing to do with him being scared. This dog does not respect you. He sees you as his follower and that is what happens to followers when they try to take something away from the leader. He warned you with a growl and any follower dog would have backed off, and if they didn't would have gotten bit, just like you did. If you do not get this issue under control NOW, Linus is going to get out of control and you will be unable to do anything to him. He may even bite you next time you try to put him in the crate. Every time something like this happens he gets more powerful and it will be more difficult for you to become the pack leader. A Dobie is very clever and not a beginners dog. As someone mentioned they will have you pegged in a second and push all your buttons. It so does not sound to me like he is scared of you what so ever. And dogs do not get their feelings hurt either. They are dogs and do not have human emotions.

He sounds like he is escalating. A pack leader can do ANYTHING to their dog. They may not like it (like nail clipping) but they sure as hell will not growl or bite.

Did you ever watch any Cesar Millan?

I can only find a select few of what he has on Youtube. However, JenS did point me to his website with all of his videos but rather difficult to navigate, it doesn't tell you what he's dealing with in that episode.

But now we know it's not him being scared, it's him thinking he's the dominate one. I just don't understand this because he has to do something before I give him anything. And I think it might be because of the other dog. He knows he's bigger than the other dog and the other dog is scared of him, so maybe he thinks I am too?

Wouldn't it show him though that I'm in control when I take his bone from him when he bites me?
 
Dont give up on him please. I think the last thing he needs is for someone to send him away again. I had an issue with Mysti growling and snapping with food and occasionally toys. I got her so I could get to her food without too much trouble, but it took alot of patience, and there were a couple times when she was older that she reverted back to trying to growl at me over a toy. It is frustrating to no end, I know, but the worst thing I think you can do to him is to send him away. Is there anyone at all you can consult with, a trainer or behaviorist that can come in to help or a breeder that is close that might be able to help you with him?

No one that is "close", but I'm doing research on Google for reviews of local trainers. Trying to find one that can actually help me with issue.
 
I can only find a select few of what he has on Youtube. However, JenS did point me to his website with all of his videos but rather difficult to navigate, it doesn't tell you what he's dealing with in that episode.

But now we know it's not him being scared, it's him thinking he's the dominate one. I just don't understand this because he has to do something before I give him anything. And I think it might be because of the other dog. He knows he's bigger than the other dog and the other dog is scared of him, so maybe he thinks I am too?

Wouldn't it show him though that I'm in control when I take his bone from him when he bites me?

If you react properly and correct the behaviour immediately, it will show him you are in command. Do not be afraid of him. Make him do what you want. If you want his bone, he has to give it to you, or his food, blanket, whatever he has, you as his pack leader should be able to take it. There's just a right way and a wrong way of establishing who is the leader and its hard to figure out what is right. Each dog is different.
 
If you react properly and correct the behaviour immediately, it will show him you are in command. Do not be afraid of him. Make him do what you want. If you want his bone, he has to give it to you, or his food, blanket, whatever he has, you as his pack leader should be able to take it. There's just a right way and a wrong way of establishing who is the leader and its hard to figure out what is right. Each dog is different.

So that's my thinking.. If he bites me and I still take his toy or whatever he has away, shouldn't he be looking at me as the leader then??
 
So that's my thinking.. If he bites me and I still take his toy or whatever he has away, shouldn't he be looking at me as the leader then??

Well, not immediately, he will try to push his limits, thats why persistence is imperative. I know he is intending to bite, maybe try to wear gloves? I dont know, Im not a pro, but I do know that it will take more than a day or two to correct this. It is something that you will have to establish every day and reinforce, eventually he will realize he cant "bully " you and he will start to accept his place.
 

Back
Top