• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Victoria Stilwell on Jacksonville Pitbull Attack Incident

ButterflyMommy

New Member
I wanted to share this blog post from Victoria Stilwell's website regarding the baby in Jacksonville who was killed by the family pet pit bull.I am a huge fan of hers, I know others may not be, but I found what she wrote in response to the incident something to be shared and get opinions on....

It Doesn't Have To Happen
Posted by Victoria Stilwell - 11/08/10

Last week I did an interview with CNN's Headline News regarding a four day old infant that had just been killed by the family’s pit bull in Jacksonville, Florida. Baby Justin was lying on the bed while his mother went to take a shower when the attack happened. The baby was taken to hospital where he died of his injuries and the pit bull was seized by animal control and euthanized the next day. First, my heart goes out to Justin’s family. As a mother I cannot imagine the pain that they are going through at the moment.

The family stated that their dog was very friendly and had no previous incidences of aggressive behavior, not even towards their other child, a four year old boy. An investigation is now underway to determine why the dog attacked and if there had been any warning signs. One of the points I made on the show, however, was something that I don’t think was on other people’s radars: Why was the most crucial piece of evidence in the case destroyed so quickly? You can interview the family all you like, their friends and neighbors. You can listen to the testimony of animal control who said that the dog was very aggressive when they went to pick him up. Well, that doesn’t surprise me because what would you do if a group of strangers came into your home to take you away? I’m sure that you would feel threatened and react in a negative way too. My question is: why was the dog euthanized before he was evaluated by a qualified behavioral specialist? The dog was put down less then twenty four hours after the attack had happened, so I don’t believe that he was seen by anyone who was able to evaluate him properly and even if someone had seen him, twenty four hours is not enough time to do a thorough temperament test and an evaluation that would help determine why the attack happened. The dog might not have been behaving aggressively at all – in fact he might have just been stimulated by the infant’s cries which could have sounded like a squeaky toy or a piece of prey to play with. All the ‘might haves’ and ‘could haves’ are now going to be just that because now the dog has been destroyed, we will never know.

Let me be clear: I’m not claiming that the dog was somehow a victim, nor am I defending him or his actions. I agree that the dog should have been put to sleep even if he had undergone the above-mentioned tests, but in order to avoid these kind of tragedies in the future, we have to find out more about what triggers such an apparently violent event so that we can build up a clearer picture of why a dog sometimes kills in this manner. I understand that it would be cruel to keep the dog alive for too long because of the stress it would be under being away from its family, and that getting a clear picture of behavior would be hard in a shelter environment, but if a professional had been able to study this dog, they would have come up with potentially valuable information that could be shared and used to prevent future attacks from happening.

Education is key, which is why I am developing a project that will spread the word about dogs and child safety, particularly for new mothers-to-be. Too many infants and young children are being mauled or killed by the family pet and it is time to take action and spread the message about safety and a parent’s responsibility. When people like me advise that an infant or young child should never be left alone with a dog even for one second, we mean it! Dogs and young children do not mix well and the combination can be a recipe for disaster. Active supervision when both are in the same room together is crucial and separation when a parent is unable to supervise is a must. Follow those simple rules and babies like Justin will be kept out of harm’s way. Life changes when a baby comes into the home and adjustments need to be made so that everyone in the household – including the new baby and the family pet – are safe and protected from each other.

And to all of those calling out for the pitbull breeds to be banned, Breed Specific Legislation (BSL), does not work! Britain, other countries, and several US states have banned pitbulls and/or certain other breeds for decades and yet child deaths from dog attacks are continuing to rise. BSL addresses the wrong end of the leash. We need to be focusing on owners and their ultimate responsibility for the animal in their care. So regardless of how you feel about the politics of the debate, the end results of such legislation speak the loudest – BSL doesn’t make the world a safer place. Let’s concentrate on the deed and not the breed and give full focus to keeping children safe around all dogs.
 
I don't particularly like her or her methods - her approach just grates on me - and I know I will probably be flammed, but why would anyone leave a 4 day old baby alone on a bed with a dog loose in the house - any dog??? why was it not in a crib? or if they did not have one, why was the bedroom door not locked? sometimes I think people just do not think - and now there is enough blame to go around to a lot of people, a dead baby, a dead dog and again more questions than answers - don't get me wrong - the pit bul was wrong, but the owner was doubly wrong and just plain neglegent for allowing the dog and the baby to be in a less than safe situation.

*shaking head* at the sensless, definitely avoidable tragedy
 
My question is: why was the dog euthanized before he was evaluated by a qualified behavioral specialist? The dog was put down less then twenty four hours after the attack had happened, so I don’t believe that he was seen by anyone who was able to evaluate him properly and even if someone had seen him, twenty four hours is not enough time to do a thorough temperament test and an evaluation that would help determine why the attack happened. The dog might not have been behaving aggressively at all – in fact he might have just been stimulated by the infant’s cries which could have sounded like a squeaky toy or a piece of prey to play with. All the ‘might haves’ and ‘could haves’ are now going to be just that because now the dog has been destroyed, we will never know.

I agree with this. That could of been the case. We will never know since the dog was not evaluated after this incident.

Also, WHY did the mother leave the child alone with the dog!! No child should be un-supervise with ANY breed of dog. I honestly think humans should be evaluated and tested before getting any pet.

-
 
Quote Originally Posted by Michele View Post
I honestly think humans should be evaluated and tested before getting any pet.
I also think this should apply to prospective parents.
That was MY first thought too! lol

I was thinking the same thing when I read the part about the dog being put down so fast. I STILL think the dog should be put down, but I have to agree that 'destroying the evidence' so quickly didn't answer some questions. I can't tell you how deeply I feel for this family. To lose your child is unthinkable. To lose him at 4 days old and in this manner, there are no words. And even losing the dog must have added to their sadness. I would not even let my sweet Buddy, who loves my grandchildren, alone with a baby like that. But while children are for the young and strong, wisdom sometimes takes many more years of living. I'm finally learning at this age that my mom was right when she said, "because I've lived longer than you and know more." Sad, sad case.
 
WOW I can't even read the entire article just enough to say....WTF was wrong with this mother???? No brains I'm sorry, you just don't leave a 4 day old baby on a bed with ANY DOG and leave the room let alone go take a shower.....I'm just shaking my head in total AWWWW....a four day old baby when it cries, think about wut that must sound like to a dog....then it's probably moving it's arms and legs......geez does this not sound and look like a sqeakie toy to the dog...maybe I'm wrong here, but you know I'm so sick of reading all these types of incidents and right away the blame goes to the dog.....the blame is to the parent or who ever was in charge of taking care of that child....not matter the age....people have no common scene.....Do I feel bad for this mother...yes cuz she now has to live with her mistake the rest of her life!!!

Sorry for ranting or sounding cold hearted for this mother but you hear these horror stories over and over, you would think that the public would get smart already.....just one more strike against the pit breed, any breed that has gotten a bad rap because of irresponsible people...there are no handbooks that come when you become a parent, there are for pets.....how many more horror stories do we have hear about before people will start to get smart and learn???
 
The more I think about this - the madder I get - I think the mother should be brought up on charges of negligent homocide - it does not take a rocket scientist to figure out several ways this horrible tragedy could have been avoided.

the sad thing is this time next year she will probably have another dog and god forbid another baby. I know thats judgmental, but being stupid should not be a defense!
 
I've not had the experience of being a mother, but I don't think i would leave a 4 day old infant on a bed even without a dog in the room. The infant could have fallen off the bed and been hurt or killed. The baby should have been in a crib without a dog in the room. If only people went through the temperament and health testing that dogs do before breeding!
 
I just can't imagine the pain they feel - but who hasn't done something without thinking for just a second especially when we live so closely with our dogs and so many people treat them like people. This family in the blink of an eye has been changed forever - they will never recover. Nothing could be worse. It was not intentional and I wish them some of God's healing peace but I fear they will never feel peace as long as they live. Nothing could be worse punishment.
 
Oh my...this is just wrong wrong wrong. I agree, regardless the dog would have needed to be put down, but Victoria S really hit the nail on the head. It could have been anything that triggered a response from that dog. From little noises the baby made to the little wiggling of fingers and toes to make it look like a new fun stuffed toy. Or even the smell of milk around the mouth.

And wow, the mother...sadly paying for her mistakes. #1 even a 4 day old baby could move around enough to roll off a bed and get hurt. #2, I could understand her wanting to shower and clean up....but IF it were me...( and I dont have kids or even ever wanted them ) I would be so...."in love, you could say" with the baby...I would most likely take it in and shower with it...making it a great bonding experience.. ( and yes..I did this with my first dober girl 13 yrs ago...we hopped in the shower together lmao )

And of course the obvious mistake of leaving the baby alone with an animal...any animal..bird, ferret. gerbil...dog, cat. That should be an obvious NO BRAINER
 
This just proves that stupid is truly an epidemic that is sweeping across the Western Civilization in proportions of the like we have never seen before.

Stupid fact #1: a newborn should never be left alone on a bed - EVER- under any circumstances
Stupid fact #2: a newborn should never be left alone with ANY type of dog -EVER- under any circumstances

I am tired of hearing tragic news linked to nothing but sheer stupidity. Yes, we are human and that means we are not perfect, fine, no problem there. But to go in a shower, where you are completely unable to hear a damn thing, and leave a defenseless, newborn on a bed alone, is inexcusable.
I do feel for the mother and the family as the pain... I just can't imagine what they are going through. But at what point do we say we should have known better. I don't need to press my hand on a stove top ring to know it will burn me. So why are we patting them on the back and saying there, there, it was that viscious dog that did it, when she is to blame. If that baby hadn't been left on the bed, then this tragedy never would have occured. Yes, hindsight is 20/20 but what the hell happened to common sense?
 

Back
Top