• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

The "No Petting" Theory

I have purchased quite a few Leerburg DVDs, because I generally like their philosophies, though Ed can be a bit annoying :D and I was listening to him talk about raising a working puppy... He says that no one in the household should pet or play with the puppy except the person who is going to be training and handling that dog. Other family members can walk or feed the puppy, but no gushing over the puppy.

I have been studying a lot, because I am hoping to get my prospective working puppy next year. I had my boyfriend listen to this theory, and he went kind of nuts. He does not agree with it one bit, and said that it would never fly if I were to get another puppy. Can anyone who is familiar with this elaborate a little bit more, and give opinions? Has anyone raised a dog this way? I can understand the theory, but it does seem a bit unrealistic.
 
Leerburg is a little nuts on some things and YES he drives me nuts. Can't stand to listen for long. This is one of his theories that is off the wall and IMHO not good for the family life. We all pet my dogs but I work them.

I will add I personally think we all are way to over gushy with our dogs and when we treat them like people with full rights that is what often causes the problems. The dog should obey basic commands from everyone in the family. My husband drives me nuts as he has his own method and it is never what I tell him to do but he and the dogs adjust. I have not found it to interfere with what I do. They know what and how I do it and they know how and what he does but they don't obey him as well always as they do me, they don't heel for him because he won't do it the way they have been trained. I finally learned not to worry about it.

These dogs are smart enough to know just like kids how to work both of us when needed -
 
Ed Frawley can absolutely be very annoying if you listen to his voice for long, LOL, but he does put out some very good training DVDs, especially the ones with Michael Ellis, and Behrnard Flinks.
The situation you are asking about, comes from I believe his how to raise a working puppy, DVD, and its similar, though a little stricter apparently, to what I teach people who want to raise a puppy, young dog for work.
The point of what he is conveying, is that you want an absolute BOND, between the person who will be handling the dog, and the dog. You dont want the dog bonding to someone else in the family, and you want the dog to learn that EVERY positive influence in his/her young life, comes from the person who will handle him. NOT from anyone else.

This isa great concept if you can do it, but its not always necessary to perform to the extent you are saying. I teach that all play, feeding, walking, should come from the person who will handle him. So for example, all toy and tug play should only come from the handler, all feeding of the dog, should come from the handler, taking the dog for a walk, should come from the handler. Now others in the house can pet and love on the dog, thats not an issue, but you want all the over the top needs, such as play drive, food drive, etc, come from the person who will handle the dog in the work.

I hope this explains things a bit better.
 
I have a working puppy and she does great. I'm the one who does the training and feeds her. But everybody else in this family spends time with her too. I think its not nessecary that the others ignore the pup. Its part of the family and thats how i want it :)
I know people who told me, i have to have sepearted from all the other dogs in my house, hell no, don't do things like that. All my dogs are familymembers and member of the pack and guess what she still is a great working pup :p and she knows when its working time and when is familytime.
I think people put to much in those Leerburg training books and DVD's, i think he gets overboard with a few things, but thats my opinion.
 
What leerburg trains is for strictly working puppies, not family dogs. They have some great information but not everything translates over for a family dog. You have to understand that what they are calling a working dog is strictly that- usually they are kennel dogs (and I don't mean that in a negative way, just different from raising a family pet) that are focused on there work and not living in a social environment with family and children and people who are out to sue you for anything. His methods are great for a dog that is only going to be doing schutzhund work or the like, I prefer my dogs to be able to socialize and be family members. They may not be the top schutzhund dogs but they will be competitve enough for me to be proud of. He also does most of his work with German Shepherds-----very different personalities than dobes.
 
Dale thanks for clarifying and I agree 100% but my hubby is hardheaded and he will do his own thing so it is divorce or just get over it. Fortunately for me it has worked out. I do the vast majority of feeding and all playing etc, but when I am gone showing he has to take up the slack (he does not play with them though). As immortaldobes said they might be talking about kennel dogs in which I would agree, but our Dobermans live inside with us and have to be socialized and able to live in a family situation.
 
That is great information. Especially the "divorce or just get over" it point :)

Stemming from this topic, is there ever an issue with having your dogs develop better bonds with each other than with you? This is something my trainer mentioned to avoid, but I haven’t had a chance to talk to him more about it. Is there a certain amount or type of interaction that you do or do not allow your dogs to have in a multiple working dog house?
 
I personally really like Michael Ellis and Ivan Balabanov are two of my favorites. I do let my dogs out together some but not til they are a little older. I take them separate places and work them alone. That way they learn from the beginning to function alone and only count on me. It is wehn two dogs are together all the time that they become co-dependent. You might enjoy reading my article on separation anxiety on http://caine-chat.com. I have other people take them for walks at training club when they are puppies - I always thought it was sad when people paid good money to have a handler and then could not even enter the building because the dog is so stressed he can't function without you.

I sit at ring side if they are showing akc and I am not handling them. I want to watch and see what happened and how the judging goes. My dogs are sport dogs - if I were training for PP or world competiton I might do it different but I want a social dog that is safe around people. I am confident to know I am still their main squeeze and when it comes time to go home they come with me.

As long as the vast majority of fun and games, feeding and training come from you I have never had a problem with it.
 
Leerburg is a little nuts on some things and YES he drives me nuts. Can't stand to listen for long. This is one of his theories that is off the wall and IMHO not good for the family life. We all pet my dogs but I work them.

I will add I personally think we all are way to over gushy with our dogs and when we treat them like people with full rights that is what often causes the problems. The dog should obey basic commands from everyone in the family. My husband drives me nuts as he has his own method and it is never what I tell him to do but he and the dogs adjust. I have not found it to interfere with what I do. They know what and how I do it and they know how and what he does but they don't obey him as well always as they do me, they don't heel for him because he won't do it the way they have been trained. I finally learned not to worry about it.

These dogs are smart enough to know just like kids how to work both of us when needed -

OMG!!! That sounds exactly like my house!! LOL!!
 
That is great information. Especially the "divorce or just get over" it point :)

Stemming from this topic, is there ever an issue with having your dogs develop better bonds with each other than with you? This is something my trainer mentioned to avoid, but I haven’t had a chance to talk to him more about it. Is there a certain amount or type of interaction that you do or do not allow your dogs to have in a multiple working dog house?

Yes, that can happen when the older dog is the one that corrects certain puppy behaviors before you do. This also stems from the two spending all their time together and the younger ends up looking to the older one for direction. that happened to me years ago and although I recognized it too late, I was able to fix it, but it took a lot of time to do so.
I want my dogs to all get along, but I am the one that breaks up little spats they may have and I work them all individually, including taking them places for socialization or proofing.
In my house, I train, feed, walk, play fetch etc. and socialize them all. My husband occasionally feeds, but he is the one that plays hands on. They always listen to me, they sometimes listen to him. He won't change his ways, which I why I tell him I insist on smart breeds only...they know his way and they know my way. They also know that I won't tolerate certain behaviors, while he lets them get away with it sometimes. He gets pissed off when he can tell them something 5 times and they still won't listen and I tell them once, and boom it's done. It's called consistency honey. You'd think he'd be tired of hearing that one. :)
 
My only experience with any kind of working dogs was as a decoy and getting chewed on three times a week, this was with one Mal who is a military dog, a Mal that belonged to a National Guard civil support team, and a Dept of Energy dog who is a Dutch Shepherd. The #2 Mal was kept at the handlers home with his family and allowed to play with everyone. The first Mal and the DS seemed like they were strictly business 24/7 while the 2nd Mal would try to play with everyone and get attention when work was done the other two seemed to want to mind their own business and not be bothered. All three of them worked their buts off when it was time to work. I think the best way to describe the differences that my untrained and inexperieced eye saw was that the two dogs that were kenneled and only handled by their handlers and kennel masters was that they seemed to be indifferent towards people, but like I said it's only three dogs so I can't say if this is a result of how they were raised.
 
Wow its times like this I wish Von Cossack was not banned on this forum - he spent decades training PP and I would love to have someone else chime in on this too. I know one of my pups went to a retired K9 officer - had a mal for bomb detection, and the state of Va required them to be housed in a kennel at the officer's house but they are not alowed to co-habitate with the families. He said that was so that the dogs would stay focused and not be distracted by family emotions - seemed sad to me a bit.

Hope someone may have some experience that they can share with us.
 
Wow its times like this I wish Von Cossack was not banned on this forum
Well this is new to me! He was a wealth of info.

I think I have decided that I will not let strangers pet my pup. I am having a challenge now with Priest in training because he constantly wants to approach everyone. I don't want my new puppy to think that he will get anything good (food or affection) from anyone but me. My b/f will obviously be the exception because we live together.

I plan on doing a lot of focus and attention work and play in public places, so he will become indifferent to strange people, and realize that I am the source of all of the fun and games. Priest is recently showing more drive when working with other people, and it's driving me crazy! I have had the exact same treats as my friend, and he would be all over her like a fly on poo, but couldn't care as much for them when they were in MY hand. And I always make training fun. I very rarely use corrections. I think keeping strangers from gushing over the puppy will help him focus on me.
 
Bythenight, the way I handled this with my youngsters is strangers were not able to walk up and come running to pet my pups - I do a body block and put my hand up and tell then straight out - no you cannot pet my puppy she/he is in training - once I had solid focus and attention, I added the command "lets go say hello" People though were always told to stand or stay where they were, I would do an about turn if I had to to get 8 to 10 feet between us. I would tell the pup to sit, get their attention and say "Lets go say hello" I always told people that they had to stay still and let me approach them, and that they had to shake my hand first and that the pup had to stay sitting to pet the pup, and they were only allowed to scratch under the chin, no over the head, leaning over petting. This has worked well for me, and we even were able to pass the CGC because it was a walking approach and shake hands then continue on.

I NEVER want my dogs to think its ok for ANY stranger to walk right up and approach and get in "our space" without an invitation. I am more comfortable with choosing who we visit. Lets go say hello also works for our therapy dog visits.
 
Well, all I can say is I do the training of my dogs and the feeding,
but I also allow certain people to pet mine, I want them to be a
member of the family as well. Hunter is not with me any longer, but
Schaudeh as a pup was full of ready to get them even as a pup, I
curbed some of that, she is very sweet, but she is on patrol and so
was my Hunter, so was my Shepherd Mateese.:guns:
 
strangers were not able to walk up and come running to pet my pups - I do a body block and put my hand up and tell then straight out - no you cannot pet my puppy she/he is in training - once I had solid focus and attention, I added the command "lets go say hello"

I love the idea of not allowing anyone to approach us, and having complete control of the situation. I guess I have to work on my assertiveness
tongue.png

I am definitely going to get one of those vests that says "working dog - do not pet." Hopefully that will help deter most people. But your method makes a lot of sense because it still allows the pup to get comfortable being touched by strange people. After all, he's going to have to be OK with a strange judge examining him.
 
strangers were not able to walk up and come running to pet my pups - I do a body block and put my hand up and tell then straight out - no you cannot pet my puppy she/he is in training - once I had solid focus and attention, I added the command "lets go say hello"

I love the idea of not allowing anyone to approach us, and having complete control of the situation. I guess I have to work on my assertiveness
tongue.png

I am definitely going to get one of those vests that says "working dog - do not pet." Hopefully that will help deter most people. But your method makes a lot of sense because it still allows the pup to get comfortable being touched by strange people. After all, he's going to have to be OK with a strange judge examining him.
 

Back
Top