• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

I finally ordered my remote trainer!

I kept putting off buying a remote trainer because I just didn't want to accept that I could
not have a perfectly trained dog with out. I've never had to use one in the past, but I have
nothing against them. For Priest's first birthday this week, he is getting the Dogtra 1900. I
most importantly need to use it for recalls. He does not always come when called, after
trying so hard to instill the command into him for months. Now he has started running
away like it's a fun game when I go to grab him, which is a huge problem for me.
I know I won't be able to use it right away. I'm going to let him wear it for a week or two.
I might order the Leerburg DVD and watch that first, too.

My question for those of you who use these devices, is What else do you use it for?

I am just curious if you use it for other bad behaviors, and if you have had success.
I thought of using it for a couple other things, but I'm not sure if it's a good idea. I have
been unsuccessful with getting him to stop putting his nose and tongue on things that
don't belong to him (my drink on the coffee table, or anything on it, and anything I am
carrying in my hand). I think this may be the only other time I will use it.

The other thing I considered, but don't think is the best idea, is to stop his whining. Sometimes
he will whine for an hour and drive me up a wall (and this will be after play, a walk, food,
and I will just have no idea what else he could possibly be whining for.)
I have always ignored it, and thought it would go away with age, but not yet.
But I don't want him to think that he can never whine when he is hurt or sick...

Any thoughts?
 
first of all find you a trainer, whow will show you how to used, if you really will get one, i never had one and probably never wanna use one.
About the whining, oh well, what can i say, i have a 16 month old here, what does that and i just live with it :p
On saturday we went to training and Apollo had to wait in a crate til it was his turn, oh well he was whinning and howling for 3 hrs non stop, i just ignored it.
the whinning is they just want your attention thats all, Apollo can do that too and i know he got hsi food and was outside, so there is nothing what he would need, he just want attention :)
i would practice the recall with a long leash, til he gets it and not using a shock collar.
if you put something in front of him, its always a 50/50 chance that they will go to it, but those you can change to with a leash and the command leave it our AUS
But i'm sure the other more experience members will jump in here.
 
Everything you've described is normal behavior for a vast majority of Dobermanns. I'm guessing this device your buying is a e-collar???? You have ZERO experience with this device????? Are you employing a quality trainer to show you the do's & don't's of this device????? Have you tried hiring a trainer to show you different mehods for different problem solving????? I'm guessing this is a young dog (what age is he/ is he intact??) I'm sorry if I'm coming across abit cold but I'm not a fan of such devices especially in the hands of novice people. If you can answered the questions I asked above I would be more then willing to help you. Also where do you live??? Thanx von Cosack Dobermann (1937----Today) Von.
 
We have a Dogtra e-collar for Shanoa. I would definitely recommend consulting with an experienced trainer. I would strongly suggest you not use the e-collar to correct behaviors that you don't want. I think what you'll end up with is a skittish, reactive dog. Your dog is just about a year old, right? I guarantee that an e-collar will not stop your dog from whining.

The only thing we use Shanoa's e-collar for is recall when we're off leash out in a dog park or somewhere else. First off, your dog must really, really know what the command means. Are you certain that he understands "come" and is just blowing you off? Have you done extensive training on that command? For example, Shanoa has always, and I literally mean always, gotten a good reward for coming when called. We never used that command unless we were certain she would come (as in, she was on a long lead, or she was already coming towards us). Then, she got a great reward for it. The only reason we use the e-collar when we're out off leash is for extra safety. Our collar has a "page" button, which is a vibration but not a stimulation. I use that on occasion when she's out of sight/hearing and I want her to come back. We trained a lot to get her to associate the page with the "come" command. I still treat her for every "come" when we're out and about. So far her recall is 100%.

The problem with using an e-collar without experience is that you can really damage your dog, both physically and mentally. It can be a great tool, and I know several of us use them, but you have to be careful with them. Do you have a trainer you can work with? It can be tricky to find one who is knowledgeable about e-collars but doesn't seem them as a solution to every problem and a way to just constantly punish your dog.

MeadowCat
 
Before anyone else respondes, please read my original post carefully as to make sure your questions were not already addressed.

Also, please note that my question is whether or not anyone uses an e-collar for anything other than recalls. I said that is the only reason I plan to use it, but was curious if anyone uses it for anything else. I only mentioned other behaviors I want to curb in order to get other suggestions. I said I did not ever want to use an e-collar, but I feel like I have no choice.

One of my biggest problems is that when we are out in the woods, Priest will find a dead animal, and will not leave it alone when I ask him to. Especially if I am far away. Then, if I approach him to get him away from it, instead of letting me grab him, he runs away and runs in circles like it's a fun game. (And NO, I never taught him to play keep away).

Also, like I said, we have been working on "come" for months. I know that he knows it well. We have always done it with treats and toys and games, and I have always set him up for success, but there are still times when he does not come on the first command, and at this point, I don't know how to curb that behavior, and I do not want him to learn that it is OK to not come right away when called the first time.
 
Thanks for clarifying what you were asking. I think we just got a bit nervous because so many people use e-collar in a very bad way.

I do think the e-collar can help you in the circumstances you are describing. If you don't have a trainer to work with, make sure you start with the lowest possible setting on the collar when you test it out. What you want is the lowest possible stimulation that will get a response. A flick of the ear is about as much as you want - it's more a reminder than you still have control than it is a punishment. I would work it first in your yard or in a controlled setting so you can see what will work for your dog. Does he know "leave it"? If so, you can use that with the dead animal.

One thing I've found is that if the e-collar is used when the dog is highly stimulated it can actually make the behavior worse. We tried to use it to help teach Shanoa to stop chasing our cats. But the stimulation would actually get her more hyped up, and it was very counter productive. Just a warning, because I didn't know that.

Like I said, an e-collar can be very valuable. Shanoa always wears her collar when she's off leash, because you just never know what circumstance might come up and I want that extra security. I haven't had to correct with her e-collar for recall in a long time.

MeadowCat
 
One thing I've found is that if the e-collar is used when the dog is highly stimulated it can actually make the behavior worse. We tried to use it to help teach Shanoa to stop chasing our cats. But the stimulation would actually get her more hyped up, and it was very counter productive. Just a warning, because I didn't know that.

This is VERY VERY helpful. I would have started with a low setting anyway, but I didn't know that this concept worked with the e-collar the same way it does for human corrections. That's great advice.
 
Good article! I like your point about the stimulation just making the response faster and more reliable. That's exactly what I'm looking for.

When you descibe using a constant stimulation, and stopping it when you get the desired response, is that what is considered escape training? I haven't decided if I should buy the Dogtra DVD, which I believe uses this method, or the Leerburg DVD, which does not.
 
We don't use that style with our e-collar. There are definitely two different methods. We used the nick button to give a correction when she blew off the command. Oh, and not to say there's anything wrong with the other method. We just thought this was more simple and it's worked great for us.
 
I've known lots of trainers that use that method also. That's just more of a correction method though, rather than a training method. I use that method with the collar once they are already trained (and much older) and they flip me the bird... :D
 
Yes, DeDe, that's pretty much the situation we were in! We didn't use it as training so much as a back up in case she blew us off while off leash.
 
I have the Dogtra 1700NCP, which was what the 1900NCP became. I love it! I also have Leerburg DVD on remote training for pet owners. It's an awesome video and I highly recommend it to pet owners considering getting into remote training. The section on recall training is great. The Leerburg video teaches you how to use the collar for corrections almost exactly as you would use a leash for corrections, and when the methods are followed carefully, very little stimulation is necessary. They do not advocate "escape" methods.

I only use my Dogtra for recall. Being able to "reach out and touch" a dog is a wonderful thing! I can't stand being blown off by a dog that knows that coming is optional when it is out of reach.
 
I have the Dogtra also and love it. I only use it for the recall. Since I can train a fast quick response for normal things and I have seen dogs want to jump out of their skin when trainers use it for basic obedience I tend not to like it. I have found with positive motivation and toy drive I can shape my dogs behavior into the desired results. But there comes a time in the recall that they just don't think you can reinforce it. I love it then as you can reach out and touch them which really gets their attention.
 
The last few posts were extremely helpful, and on point with exactly where I am coming from right now. Thank you! I hate having to limit any dog's freedom. I've never had a dog in the past that blew me off like this, and I just really want to nip it in the butt with Priest before it's too late.

And I am glad to hear that Apollo is a whiner, too! I guess I will just continue to ignore it. It's not an every day thing, but when he starts, it goes on and on and on... I've just never had a dog with so many quirks before! (All of my GSDs were perfect little angels! hehe)
 
to funny, because i had a few GSD before and i still have one here LOL
so seems like we have lots in common :p
don't give up, he will get it on the end :)
 
UPDATE/QUESTION

After conditioning Priest to the collar for 2-3 weeks, and watching the Leerburg DVD (all nearly 3 hrs!) I started using it. 5 mins last night, and 5 mins today. So far, so good!

My question is... after you start using it, do you only put the collar on when you're going to use it? Ovbiously they're not going to wear it on every occasion, but it seems to me like Priest will start to figure it out at this point. Should he wear it on every walk?
 
I personally only use mine when we're going to be off leash in an area that I want extra control. The collar tends to give Shanoa some bald spots on her neck just from wearing it, so I don't like her to wear it that often. Plus, an e-collar needs to be on fairly tight, and especially in the summer I don't want her to have anything that tight on unless we have to. But yes, she definitely understands when she's wearing it and when she's not!
 

Back
Top