• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Rant about what happened at class. Questioning if he is going through a fear period? Totally unusual behavior for him…

remy

Active Member
Remy had class tonight and I have been thinking about it ever since, so I wanted to see what you guys think and vent a little. Warning that this will be a bit long.

Just for some background info, he started puppy classes when he was about 4 months old. He also went to handling class. I intended to continue classes after that but the facility closes during the summer. A few weeks ago we started 2 more classes (rally and group beginner/intermediate obedience). He has been doing really well with these so far, especially the rally class. The rally instructor is the same one from the puppy class (I really like her) and the other class is a new instructor, who brings her dogs and they stay in kennels during classes. I also want to mention that since I’ve had him he hasn’t really played with other dogs. Only 2 times did he play off leash with another dog briefly. Most people I know have dogs who are reactiveand/or aggressive and I also don’t have a fenced in yard, so he doesn’t get off leash play with other dogs at my house.

Tonight he acted completely different than usual. I don’t know if it’s just because of the circumstances of what happened, maybe a fear period or both? Could it be because he doesn’t usually play with other dogs/have them in such close proximity? I’ll explain a bit of what happened at class, this will be the rant-y part.

When we first got there he was focused and responsive to commands. This changed drastically as class went on. All of the dogs were on place when multiple French Bulldogs maybe 6?) were let out of kennels and managed to escape past the fenced off area. Remy was faced towards me while laying down when 3 of the dogs ran up behind him. 2 of them initially got onto the cot with him which caused him to stand up. The other dog was running around the cot. Since the dogs would not leave us alone, I took Remy off of the cot and walked a few feet away. All 3 of the dogs continued to follow us and circle him. He was not aggressive towards them at all (no barking, growling, lunging etc) but was trying to remove himself from the loose dogs. I was very unhappy with the situation because it shouldn’t have happened. The trainer was playing it off as being a good distraction, which yes it was, but I don’t think that was appropriate.

After that happened he began to get stressed and was a little jumpy when the other dogs were in close proximity to him. (Again, not a normal behavior for him.) He was reluctant to do basic commands that he knows well, even things like “sit.” Eventually he was a little more receptive but nowhere near how he usually is during class. We continued on with class and maybe 15-20 minutes later nearly the same thing happened again! The biggest difference was that this time it was 2 dogs and not 3. After this he started acting even worse. For a minute I couldn’t even convince him to walk… I have NEVER seen him act this way. He is usually a very confident dog. To make things even worse, towards the end of the class a Poodle lunged at him barking several times. He is not typically phased by dogs barking at him, but after everything else that happened he was on edge. At this point he tried to back away. He was not confrontational or aggressive during any of these 3 situations.

After all of this happened I am feeling a bit discouraged. I tend to think the worst case scenario lol. My worry is that this will set him back in some way. I also wonder if perhaps he is going through a fear period? If he is, how do I deal with this without making things worse? I don’t know if this would be considered a “normal” reaction to what happened, but since I’ve never seen him act this way I thought it was a bit of an extreme reaction (for him.)

Another thing that bothered me was that the trainer didn’t seem to think this was a big deal, and even said to me his body language wasn’t that of a scared dog… Mind you she is also a behaviorist. She knows I want to do show and sports with Remy and made a comment about how this (meaning the class) was real life and “AKC dogs” are not as well trained in “real life” as they are for show. I am seriously debating not going back to this class even though I know I won’t be able to get my money back.
 
With Remy, I would act like it never happened and treat him no different than usual. Before I went back to this class, I may do a lot of my own self confidence work with Remy. Climbing aluminum bleachers, sit long stays on patio tables in a park, climbing over and on trees that have fallen, controlled walks in/around shopping plazas- all of this with his favorite treats and a lot of praise.

Then when going back to the class, my head is always on a swivel, and being prepared for any given situation. I would not have let the French Bulldogs get close to him while they were unleashed and Remy being leashed. The owner would have been very upset with me because I would have been popping the concrete in front of them with the leash handle and booming that the get back. Reason I am pretty drastic here is because we had a French Bulldog down the road that would run free while Ragnar was on a leash walking with me. The FB would come up yippy and barking at Ragnar and I was expecting Ragnar to hold his cool and ignore the distraction. That right there caused him to hate little yippy dogs…especially light colored small dogs. And him being leashed and not free like the other dogs makes him even more stressed because he feel a cornered and restricted.

And the poodle….I know during these events dogs are doing obedience all around you in a circle or side by side pretty close but you have to see that poodle lunge before he does it. Head on a swivel and reading every behavior and movement to decider if friend or foe.
 
Thank you for the advice!
Before I went back to this class, I may do a lot of my own self confidence work with Remy. Climbing aluminum bleachers, sit long stays on patio tables in a park, climbing over and on trees that have fallen, controlled walks in/around shopping plazas- all of this with his favorite treats and a lot of praise.
These are all typical things we do, minus the bleachers, so I will continue exposing him to new things! He is very good with all different sounds, sights, textures, etc… I was honestly shocked that he had the reaction he did.
I would not have let the French Bulldogs get close to him while they were unleashed and Remy being leashed.
Unfortunately I didn’t see them until it was already too late. No one said anything either until the French Bulldogs started to approach the dogs in class. They came from the far left back corner of the room, while we were in the front right side. The other loose dogs went to dogs on the left side. There was a wall on our right and in each direction of use there were other dogs in place.
And the poodle….I know during these events dogs are doing obedience all around you in a circle or side by side pretty close but you have to see that poodle lunge before he does it. Head on a swivel and reading every behavior and movement to decider if friend or foe.
Definitely! I feel like I need to be extra cautious during this class now. Towards the end I was very focused on him so I may have just missed the signs with the poodle. I have noticed a lot of people don’t pay much attention to their dogs (at the class and in public.) So many times, including today, I see dogs fully extended on their leash behind the owner while they are talking with someone or while shopping in a store etc…
 
Remy is probably fine but yes it would be annoying this happened twice in one go. The trainer should know better. An accident/one time is one thing, twice in one night is another. Thats rude behavior of the dogs and careless of the trainer/owner. Remy was being very appropriate trying to avoid, he likely didn't want conflict HOWEVER, I would not put it past my dog to correct another dog for being rude and that is why I think the trainer is a little too careless about the situation happening twice in one night. This is a doberman, they are allowed to be dog aggressive, it is in the breed. Up against a smaller dog? Dangerous. Yes, we want well behaved dogs but lets not push them either. The whole point is to make them feel confident and comfortable that nothing will happen to them, not actually have things happen to them and say "oh well".

Since you already paid for the class, I would mention these things with the trainer as a last attempt at communicating a problem I see. If there isn't any resolve, I would not be afraid to lose my money and stick with the trainer you feel comfortable with. There will be other opportunities to do other classes in the future.
 
I think Remy is fine too. And as @Ddski5 said, I would act like it didn't happen and not treat him differently. I'm thinking Remy was more confused than afraid. He probably wanted to please you, but had to keep his own head & thoughts on the loose dogs, and his mind was simply elsewhere when you were asking him to do his exercises.

I personally wouldn't drop out of the class. I would hope he could do the next class with no surprises, thus giving him confidence that it's not always going to be the chaotic mess it was last time. This is the same facility as your class with the trainer you like? How do you think that trainer would have handled it differently? Did the Franchies come from an area that had nothing to do with your class, like a boarding section (you said they were let out of their kennels)? So the instructor had nothing to do with the loose dogs, just said it was definitely a good distraction event? So yeah, accidents happen, whoever let the dogs run loose is at fault. The instructor should have a word with whoever was at fault, and be assured it won't happen again. IF something like this happens again, at that facility or "in the wild", always advocate for your dog. Get between him and the loose dog(s) as best you can, get his collar and hold him behind you, I don't care how silly it looks, especially with a small dog being the culprit. Remy needs to know that you are in charge and will take care of the situation. This gives him confidence in you, plus you've put him in a place (with your hand on his collar) so he knows where you want him. This takes care of him trying to figure out what you want him to do - you make it very clear to him: "Stand back, I've got this".
 
This is the same facility as your class with the trainer you like? How do you think that trainer would have handled it differently? Did the Franchies come from an area that had nothing to do with your class, like a boarding section (you said they were let out of their kennels)? So the instructor had nothing to do with the loose dogs, just said it was definitely a good distraction event? So yeah, accidents happen, whoever let the dogs run loose is at fault. The instructor should have a word with whoever was at fault, and be assured it won't happen again.
I accidentally removed your first paragraph, but I’m glad you guys feel it will just be a one time type deal. I got thinking about everything afterwards and wondered if it would effect him in some way. (Spiraling thoughts lol) He takes all of his classes there so I don’t want him to feel like this is something that will happen when he’s there.

Yes it is the same facility. This trainer started working there a few months ago. Previously the only dogs in the building would be the ones in class, however the new trainer brings her dogs and also does day training. One of the reasons I’m annoyed with the dogs continuing to get loose was because the trainer is the one who let them out of the kennels… I’m not really sure why. In the back corner there are 3 large kennel (like the 4x4 or 6x4 ones) and to separate them from the rest of the room is some lattice type fencing. I’m assuming the dogs got out when she went to leave the fenced area/close the gate.

I made this little sketch on my phone to show the layout of the room. It’s very big so of course things weren’t as close as they look, the beds on the left side were probably 15-20ft from the fencing. The top left is the kennels and fencing. The squares were where dogs were on place, Remy and I being the red square. When I took him off and walked away we went down towards the bottom right. The two dogs ahead of us were also French Bulldogs. Interestingly the loose dogs didn’t really bother them, but instead went towards Remy and the two dogs on the left. All larger dogs, a Poodle, GSD and Doberman of course.
D84A0E32-F05E-4E4F-90AB-52F6C8353BCE.webp
 
Remy is probably fine but yes it would be annoying this happened twice in one go. The trainer should know better. An accident/one time is one thing, twice in one night is another. Thats rude behavior of the dogs and careless of the trainer/owner.
I will say I’m relieved you all think he will be fine. Maybe I’m a little dramatic lol, but after seeing him act the way he did I worried if this would be a negative experience for him. All of his classes are held at that building so I don’t want him to have any bad associations.
Remy was being very appropriate trying to avoid, he likely didn't want conflict HOWEVER, I would not put it past my dog to correct another dog for being rude and that is why I think the trainer is a little too careless about the situation happening twice in one night. This is a doberman, they are allowed to be dog aggressive, it is in the breed. Up against a smaller dog? Dangerous. Yes, we want well behaved dogs but lets not push them either.
I agree about it being careless. Another dog in class was a GSD who has been working on some reactivity issues and is typically muzzled. It wasn’t wearing one last night and one of the loose dogs ran up to it. Luckily there were two people with the GSD so the other one picked the loose dog up out of the way.
The whole point is to make them feel confident and comfortable that nothing will happen to them, not actually have things happen to them and say "oh well".

Since you already paid for the class, I would mention these things with the trainer as a last attempt at communicating a problem I see. If there isn't any resolve, I would not be afraid to lose my money and stick with the trainer you feel comfortable with. There will be other opportunities to do other classes in the future.
I will continue going back for now. If it continues to happen though that is when I will probably decided to drop the class. I did talk to her a little last night but somehow the conversation ended with her asking how he’s doing with heeling and loose leash walking… (which heeling and place with distractions were the main part of class last night so she has already seen him do it.)
 
I have noticed a lot of people don’t pay much attention to their dogs (at the class and in public.) So many times, including today, I see dogs fully extended on their leash behind the owner while they are talking with someone or while shopping in a store etc…
People are fricking idiots…yippy dog owners especially.

My next door neighbors friend let their little “muffles” bark up a storm and approach my Doberman growling- from the neighbors driveway coming into my driveway on the sides. I used it as a training opportunity and held Ragnar in a long stoic sit. I really wish I had video- Muffles was offleash and kept coming towards us barking/growling. The owner thought it was funny that her dog “thinks” she is a giant wolf….Rag had enough. I saw it before it happened but was not fast enough. He turned and looked at me and then broke his sit tearing after that little piece of shit. Muffles immediately turned and ran squealing like a little piglet. The owner was drinking a Smoothie and threw it at Ragnar but was way off and it splattered all over her car windshield. Ragnar was pissed and had it cornered under a car up in the tire well. His bark and growl sounded like a fricking Grizzly bear under their carport. I tried to call him off but he was way way deep into the frenzy- no way. I had to get a leash and go over there to get him back to present reality. He was pissed. Damn owner was running around the car screaming muffles muffles muffles…

I am sure as Remy grows and has more training and experiences he will be able to reflect and categorize what to do and how to do based on your training expectations. I don’t think he was scared….I just think he did not know what to do, like- what the hell is going on? What’s happening here? and you being the only responsible dog owner, you handled him correctly for his safety.

Use this experience and learn….Always-Always keep your head on a swivel and expect that jackass to not have control over that poodle. Always look for the way out of a situation that escalates because the big badass Doberman will prob be at fault no matter what. I am always willing and capable to kick punt a dog that does not have my permission to be inside 3ft of my security zone.

Also, as you train more and experience more with Remy, you will learn his “tells” and signs. You will be able to read him like a book and see it happen before it happens.
 
I am with @Ddski5, I would have been shouting at the loose dogs and been pretty upset about the situation. Agree that the trainer/behaviorist is careless with the situation. In my experience; training class was always about 'testing' the dogs safely, not where there could have been a dog fight...then Remy may not have gotten through that. And yes, the Doberman gets the blame even when they are the victim.
 
Your rant feels so familiar to me as I was also worried about Kaiser becoming dog reactive/aggressive. I do think he will be fine. On one hand, yes it’s real life, but it is also supposed to be a controlled environment which is why you pay for a class versus dealing with real life for free. Maybe you can tell that to the instructor next time she wants to exonerate herself of responsibility.

That right there caused him to hate little yippy dogs…especially light colored small dogs.
Same for Kaiser.

I would act like it didn't happen
Yes act normal and unconcerned and he will follow your lead.
Spiraling thoughts lol)
Been there, done that 😆
The owner was drinking a Smoothie and threw it at Ragnar but was way off and it splattered all over her car windshield.
:rofl: :rofl: Priceless!!!
Damn owner was running around the car screaming muffles muffles muffles…
🤣 Omg hilarious story! We had a similar incident with our neighbors yappy dog and my hb let Kaiser go after him. Kaiser was in that dogs face so fast he rolled him over and pinned him. The little furry rat squealed like a pig. The owner picked up her dog and tried to kick Kaiser but he saw the foot coming and circled around her and she lost her balance dropping the dog. The yapper rolled on the grass and Kaiser pinned him again omg it was such a riot.:spit: Dobermans for the win 🏆:dobe:
 
It was the instructors dogs.
I missed that somehow. I was assuming the class was in one place and the dogs were let out in another fenced place and came through an open gate or something.

The owner was drinking a Smoothie and threw it at Ragnar but was way off and it splattered all over her car windshield.
:rofl: :rofl: Priceless!!!

We really really wish that was on video!
 
One of the reasons I’m annoyed with the dogs continuing to get loose was because the trainer is the one who let them out of the kennels… I’m not really sure why. In the back corner there are 3 large kennel (like the 4x4 or 6x4 ones) and to separate them from the rest of the room is some lattice type fencing. I’m assuming the dogs got out when she went to leave the fenced area/close the gate.
That's pretty bad. Even if it was an accident which I'm assuming it was. Hopefully he/she will be more mindful of this in the future. If not, then the owner/manager of the facility might be advised of the lack of professionalism going on.

I will say I’m relieved you all think he will be fine. Maybe I’m a little dramatic lol, but after seeing him act the way he did I worried if this would be a negative experience for him. All of his classes are held at that building so I don’t want him to have any bad associations.
You are right to be concerned, I was just like that my first year or two with Asha because she was SO reactive and I had to go through all these experiences not knowing if I was doing the right thing, should I do more of this or less of that etc etc. Your coming here to discuss your worries is exactly how you'll learn. Keep an open mind, use what works best with Remy and you.
 
I’ve never experienced the exact situation that you had. But we have encountered off leash dogs and if Stassi is on leash or under obedience off leash she doesn’t react well to them.
Now this might sound woo woo and very unscientific. But my dogs poor reaction seems to come from a place of confusion and frustration. Almost as if she is pissed that she’s trying to do the right thing and keep herself under control, and that the other dogs aren’t having to play by the same rules she does.
 
I agree with all of the comments here and the trainer was wrong when he's trying to do what he's supposed to be doing. Those aren't good distractions and this is supposed to be structured training time, not strange dog socialization time. Our original trainer would let her GSD come into the ring but he would sit/stay in whichever spot she told him to.
 

Back
Top