• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Is there hope?

VexingEve

Novitiate
Chronos is a 16 month old, neutered male. We did a LOT of research before we got him so training started with him on day one.
He is walked every day, twice, for 2 hours. He is trained for 30 minutes every day. He is last to enter every door and gets nothing without a whole series of tricks and commands. He's never allowed on the furniture and has never set foot on my bed.

I feel like we've done everything right.

Then he turned 9 months old.

After that he became a different dog. He ignored. He resource guarded pieces of paper he'd get to the point of attempting to bite us when we retrieved it. He barks and lunges at passing dogs on walks and he entirely loses his mind when we have a guest over.

In short, we're being held captive by this dog. My kids can no longer have over friends for fear he'll bite them (as he bit my father in law) and we all walk on egg shells wondering when he'll turn. I hate that we wanted a dog for so long and now everyone in the house is afraid of him or flat out hates him.

I'm taking him into training with a professional (Local K9 officer who trains on his days off) and we're progressing that way.
But here's my question...

IS THERE ANY HOPE?!

Have any of you had a dog that seems to have slipped to the dark side that, through training, was actually able to be brought back into civilized society? Will we ever be able to have friends over again? Will we ever be able to take him on hikes and camping with us so he can be part of the family again?

Have any of you ever had your dog come back and be a "good boy" after taking such a dark turn?
 
Welcome!

Well, I can't provide the specific answer that you seek. I have not had that particular problem. By your description, you have really been vigilant with this Dobe! Good on you, by the way!

One thing I might offer is that his behaviors might not really be him having gone to the dark side or anything like that. I don't know that it is evil. It sounds like a particularly spirited, perhaps also dominant, Dobe who hit the Doberteens and for whatever reason all your training and correct handling was not enough, or not what was required. It sounds like you have a tough one on your hands.

I would imagine that, yes, he can be brought through this. If your off-duty K9 guy is worth his salt, he will probably be able to get you and your handful of a Dobe through this. One thing to be aware of, however, is that in all likelihood your trainer is experienced with Malinois and German Shepherds. A lot of training principles are pretty much universal, but it can be somewhat different training a Dobe.

Hang in there. It does sound very unpleasant, the home environment with the stress and worry and disillusion. I know what it's like to have a stressed household due to dog problems.
 
Have any of you had a dog that seems to have slipped to the dark side that, through training, was actually able to be brought back into civilized society?
Reading this makes me relieved that you already mentioned having a good trainer. Someone who has handled police dogs will likely be a great starting point instead of wasting time with pure positive only trainers who would only make the situation worse.

Sounds like you used NILIF training which is great (we still use it!), but sometimes it's not enough with such a dominant personality. It takes firm but fair leadership to keep a Doberman on the straight and narrow, but a Doberteen is a whole other ball game. During this time, they act like they have forgotten all their training and it can feel really defeating especially if you've been struggling for months before the teen stage hit, lol, the memories! It is a phase though, so yes, you will get through it.

Is this your first dog? First working breed?
 
What happens on your part when Chronos began ignoring you, snapping at the kids etc? Where is his down stay when kids come over to visit? What happened to boundaries? If you can keep him off the furniture you should be able to tell him to down-stay on his place. If not, you should put him in his crate while you have company. Is he even crate trained? Do you play games with him? Tug, ball, fetch? Something with you and fun? Do you reward with treats to let him know you have good things to offer, not just commands? I'm throwing these questions out for you to ask yourself, to reason out where & when things started going south in his behavior. These dogs - especially doberteens - will take a mile if you give an inch. If "no" means nothing to him when you say it, get a high end e-collar (not the cheap ones at pet stores) and begin training with that. Firm but Fair is a mantra around here. Nagging (saying no over and over with no results) will just encourage your dog to see how far he can push you. The answer to your question is YES, but it all depends on you and your family will have to be on board with you.

Best of luck with your new trainer, stay in touch here and let us know how it goes.
 
Try to not lose hope, despite your difficulties and stress. I also want to ask you and your family to try to not hate your dog.
Regardless of how unruly and rebellious he is, he is not happy either and not able to help himself. Animals very much absorb emotions in a household.
I hope your trainer will be able to help. Please don't disappear, keep us posted, so others can also be helped:)
 
Hang in there! Other people on here are much more knowledgeable than me, but sending you good vibes! Also, I'm seconding @Ravenbird's e-collar suggestion. It was a great help for a previous difficult dog of mine!
 
What happens on your part when Chronos began ignoring you, snapping at the kids etc? Where is his down stay when kids come over to visit? What happened to boundaries? If you can keep him off the furniture you should be able to tell him to down-stay on his place. If not, you should put him in his crate while you have company. Is he even crate trained? Do you play games with him? Tug, ball, fetch? Something with you and fun? Do you reward with treats to let him know you have good things to offer, not just commands? I'm throwing these questions out for you to ask yourself, to reason out where & when things started going south in his behavior. These dogs - especially doberteens - will take a mile if you give an inch. If "no" means nothing to him when you say it, get a high end e-collar (not the cheap ones at pet stores) and begin training with that. Firm but Fair is a mantra around here. Nagging (saying no over and over with no results) will just encourage your dog to see how far he can push you. The answer to your question is YES, but it all depends on you and your family will have to be on board with you.

Best of luck with your new trainer, stay in touch here and let us know how it goes.
True
 
I am sure you will get your good boy back, especially with a good trainer to help you with him.

Just wanted to say that it helps if you can stay as unemotional as possible when overcoming bad behaviour. Anger, frustration or fear will be picked up by Chronos very easily and possibly seen as weakness so being as calm and low key as possible is best, but firm and consistent with the boundaries. Hard to do I know!
 
Reading this makes me relieved that you already mentioned having a good trainer. Someone who has handled police dogs will likely be a great starting point instead of wasting time with pure positive only trainers who would only make the situation worse.

Sounds like you used NILIF training which is great (we still use it!), but sometimes it's not enough with such a dominant personality. It takes firm but fair leadership to keep a Doberman on the straight and narrow, but a Doberteen is a whole other ball game. During this time, they act like they have forgotten all their training and it can feel really defeating especially if you've been struggling for months before the teen stage hit, lol, the memories! It is a phase though, so yes, you will get through it.

Is this your first dog? First working breed?
He is my husband's first dog. I grew up with dogs, but they were always rough collies... needless to say a WHOLE different breed.
 
To answer all the questions...
He's actually pretty obedient in every day moments. He "sits" and "gets down" with a single command. And yes, from day one commands were always backed up with treats. It's just the moment a new person enters the house he goes into full protection mode and won't obey at all.

I will say when the new trainer came to meet him the first time Chro barked and growled and hackled until the trainer held out his hand. Chro sniffed him, backed up and continued barking like mad. The trainer's diagnosis was "fear" rather than aggression so we're working on building confidence. I just wonder if doing that can actually turn a dog around from this extreme state and if anyone has had a teen dog that eventually came out of it.

Since writing this I have been to the first class. We switched from a halter to a prong collar and immediately his fear reactions while walking nearly stopped. He does his "Chewbacca" rumble as they pass, but then he turns and looks at me. He's never done that before. It's a glimmer of hope toward change but it still feels like so far to go.
 

Back
Top