Dismiss Notice
Hello Guest!
We are glad you found us, if you find anything useful here please consider registering to see more content and get involved with our great community members, it takes less than a minute!

Had someone make a negative comment about cropped ears.

Discussion in 'Doberman Talk and Discussions' started by C908, Nov 29, 2019.

  1. C908

    C908 Notable member

    I walk Preacher at the State Fairgrounds everyday. There is a homeless woman that lives on the campground with her son. Since I have seen her living there since last summer I became intrigued wondering what her story was. We finally talked and I found out she lives there with her 24 year old son, 2 dogs and 6 cats. They were living in a tent but then got an old camper when the weather turned cold. Her son works at a factory so he pays for everything. She told me she loves animals and because she has so many nobody will rent them a house. She also said she hates anybody that is mean to animals. Our conversation was going pretty good and then she says your dog has really pretty ears but oh the pain and suffering he had to go through. I think this lady has some issues because she mentioned quitting her factory job because she would have killed somebody if she stayed. She also talked about taking medications for anxiety and depression. I think I will keep my distance from her.

    • Agree Agree x 5
    • Like Like x 3
  2. Ravenbird

    Ravenbird Notable member

    I think it was kind of you to chat with her a bit, so many homeless have issues, mostly mental, but also most are harmless. I too would probably keep my distance, but I just wanted to say you are kinder than most to at least make some conversation with her. And many, homeless or wealthy, say the same "tisk-tisk"s about the cruelty of ear trims.
    • Agree Agree x 6
    • Like Like x 3
    • Appreciation Appreciation x 1
  3. Skatchkeb

    Skatchkeb Member

    Shouldve thrown her a fiver and a smoke
    • Funny Funny x 1
  4. luckybeemer

    luckybeemer Member

    I just had my first "negative" comment about Remi's cropped ears from my aunt during Thanksgiving dinner. I just answered her question..."did you have her ears cut?" My reply "yes I did, they are not open wounds, they are healed and she is beautiful imo." Then I continued on with the convo I was having with my father. Nothing else was said about her ears. But she got lots of lovin.
    • Like Like x 3
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Appreciation Appreciation x 1
  5. JasonW

    JasonW Novitiate

    I thought it was just something certain kinds of Doberman had - so they actually get cut to look that shape? Is there a purpose to it?
    • Funny Funny x 1
  6. strykerdobe

    strykerdobe Hot Topics Subscriber

    Funny we just had a negative comment said to us at our friends pet store. We had our 21week old pup without his ears posts in. A women came up to us and asked if she could pet him. I said yes. Then she says aww you had his ears clipped. Now that really :censored: PISSED ME OFF! I said in a very loud voice YES I DID! She left! :rofl:

    I refuse not to say something to these :censored: people!
    • Agree Agree x 2
    • Funny Funny x 2
  7. obbanner

    obbanner $ Premium Subscriber $ Hot Topics Subscriber

    Unfortunately, we live in an age of ignorant busybodies. I think it's because too many want to morally preen about what really, really, great people they are rather than learn about the world. My response is to ask of they disapprove of spaying or neutering their dogs, which is much more painful than cropping or docking.

    I had Dobies since the '80s and never had anyone belly ache about cropped ears until I got AJ May, 2018. On his first visit to the vet, a couple my age were in the waiting room and the husband nudged his wife and said disapprovingly as they looked at me, "Poor doberman, cropped ears." That's at a rural practice where I remember the days when the vet would castrate pigs in pickup trucks in his parking lot! I didn't expect to get any comments at that practice and especially from anyone my generation.

    We have a Sheltie and I belong to a closed group on Facebook for Sheltie people that was started by someone who lives nearby. Almost everyone on the page is a pet owner, not working dog people. When I was posting AJ's ears, I made the joke picture below and got hit by several trolls when I posted it on the Sheltie page.


    Another troll incident. I made a video about dumbbell training which I posted on this forum as a response to someone asking about how to train a Dobie to retrieve a dumbbell. I was very surprised to see that many people are watching it, as it's a publicly available video. As of this writing, it has over 7,000 views, 23 likes and 9 dislikes. I deleted all the snarky comments about Anna wearing an e-collar. I use an e-collar for training. However, I train in a park with a leash rule, and the park employees look the other way when I train because they know my dogs are on an e-collar. I also consider the e-collar as insurance because there's deer and bear in the park, and with the e-collar, I have a chance to call them off if they start chasing a deer or a bear.
    • Like Like x 3
    • Agree Agree x 1
  8. biaham876

    biaham876 New Member

    People have a tendency to say strange things...
    The other day a woman was complimenting Neo and then said “but aren’t they aggressive??” As she was petting him and he was calmly sitting, while her mini-something was being crazy. I never realized there was such a stigma around dobermans. Now that he is bigger we get all kinds of looks and comments.
    I think it’s hilarious...hopefully no one catches him getting scared at the leaves that blow by as we are walking.
    • Funny Funny x 2
  9. jack6hd

    jack6hd New Member

    My reply to a complaint about the pain with my males ear crop was to say it was not as bad as when he was neutered. There was an infection and he had pain from that.
    • Agree Agree x 2
  10. BamMoMoMommy

    BamMoMoMommy $ Premium Subscriber $ $ Forum Donor $

    I'm sorry you got trolled(I can only imagine how ugly it got)


    Bingo.... ya'can't fix stupid.
    We've been Dobie owners for so long...now days for us and the stupid stuff people say.... it is thick skin and water off a ducks back.My husband's go to line when someone said/says something about cropped ears:

    "Nope. He came from the Hell Hound Factory that way" and keeps moving.

    I wonder sometimes how many people out there are wondering where this "Hell Hound Factory" is.....I wonder how many go home and Google it.
    • Funny Funny x 3
    • Appreciation Appreciation x 1
  11. breezyy493

    breezyy493 New Member

    Just got our second Doberman with her ears cropped, went to the pet store and two women looked at me with disgust, asked how old the dog was, while the cashier who had helped me with the other dog tisked at me too... maybe it’s the part of CA we live in, but I forgot that when we post/crop I need to expect pretty much any time in public while posting I will get some sort of hateful look or comment. Rough when the pup is socializing age and any time in public is stressful wondering who’s gonna say something next...
    • Empathetic Empathetic x 4
  12. MyBuddy

    MyBuddy Moderator Hot Topics Subscriber

    Did they have pierced ears?? A boob job? Tubes ties? You get my drift. :evilgrin: I swear, the older I get, the less I put up with people and SAY something! I probably would have sighed and said, Get over yourself!


    Pretend to hold my Big Bad Doberman back and say, Now you've done it!! HE'S MAD!!! RUN FOR YOU LIFE!!!!
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Funny Funny x 1
  13. BamMoMoMommy

    BamMoMoMommy $ Premium Subscriber $ $ Forum Donor $

    I think, if possible.... I would find me another pet store;)

    I think obbanner nailed it:

    ^^^^^^^ Bingo....Bingo...BINGO!

    We were out to dinner one night with several co workers...and one of the guys asked to see pics of Mo and Bam...I pulled out my phone...was showing him.....another co worker leaned in to look and said
    "Oh you crop."

    And yeah..I smelled the venom mixed with the vodka from her "Cosmo".

    I didn't say a thing, I just nodded and kept flipping thru pics talking about the adventures we were having with them....but....the other person wasn't gonna let it go. She started on about how cruel it was....I smiled at the guy I was showing the pics to and put my phone away...and tried to change the subject...but nope it wasn't going to change. I started trying to explain to her the history of why the crop and dock....then the process...to her "but-but-but-but"

    My husband shut her down when she said
    "The animal can't consent!"
    My husband said
    "Doesn't matter...he is a minor...til he turns 18, my house, my rules. Once he turns 18, he can do whatever he wants with his ears."

    Everyone cracked up..tension broke and she shut up.
    Mo came to us cropped.....we have only had one pup we got thru the post stages....he came to us from someone who knew they were in over their head with the breed/ the work it takes with posting/the vet bills and chewed up work boots..... and knew my husband was familiar with the breed and posting and all that goes with the devangels. (We had a guy we nicked named devangel...cuz he was a solid 50/50 mix of devil and angel.)

    We don't have a preference....if the puppy is happy, healthy and well cared for...then to each their own.

    The best thing you can do...and I know easier said then done...but don't let them get to you. Vent with folks who can/will commiserate:)
    You know your pups are happy, healthy and much loved....the rest of the world who doesn't get that...can go take a long walk off a short pier.;)
    (And FWIW...it could be worse....my oldest daughter does pit rescue....the things that get said to her and her husband{threats made}....more unbelievable then anything I have ever had said to me about any of my dober guys.)
    • Like Like x 2
  14. breezyy493

    breezyy493 New Member

    [QUOTE="MyBuddy, post: 602528, member: 771"
    Pretend to hold my Big Bad Doberman back and say, Now you've done it!! HE'S MAD!!! RUN FOR YOU LIFE!!!![/QUOTE]

    I should have said that to the lady who asked me at the dog park if my dobie (the older one, with crop) was friendly that! The funny thing is my dog was just trotting through the park and the woman who asked has a pit bull ‍♀️
  15. breezyy493

    breezyy493 New Member

    I LOVE the 18 response. It’s light hearted enough to sort of change subject and call it how it is. & yes devangel is perfect. Our older one is sort of protesting the new one, she finally grew out of eating our socks, and now if we’re holding the puppy she comes sulking out with a sock in her mouth ‍♀️‍♀️ It’s sad and funny, but I think she’s getting used to it. Right now, she’s curled up next to me and the puppy, when two days ago there was no way she’d come close. Progress!!!

Share This Page