Search results

  1. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    A discussion of what Schutzhund is, was, or should be is a lengthy topic in itself. Without going too deep into the subject it's difficult to convey a big picture. Schutzhund as a test is a means of measuring a dogs temperament. It's not a perfect test by any means and that is a lengthy...
  2. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    I see that the term “human aggression” is being perceived as a negative thing. That's fine, we can call the trait something else. There are a lot of temperament traits that make up a particular breed. Sometimes the same traits are desirable for many different breeds. Take prey drive as an...
  3. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    I’m not seeing anything in the description that says human aggression is disqualifying. The ability to unleash hellfire and brimstone on a human is NOT something present in most domestic dog breeds. It is a specific temperament trait. Perhaps it’s just a matter of semantics but you’ve got to...
  4. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    If your intent was to open a discussion about temperament in and of itself: bringing up any mention the AKC’s past history regarding Temperament Testing (ie: Schutzhund) is a sure fire way to derail the conversation. LOL, especially if an old GSD person happens to join in!!! Addressing...
  5. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    Hmmm…. Perhaps I misunderstood the point of your thread? I though your point was that prior to 1989 both “Show” and “Working” dog people were on the same sheet of music, but then Animal Rights groups disrupted the harmonious relationship by getting the AKC to stop supporting Working Trials...
  6. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    Any discussion on this must start with a definition of “correct” conformation. A dog can meet the breed standard but still be easily nitpicked apart by a show/conformation enthusiast. IMO “correct” conformation is anything from a minimally acceptable structure on up to someone’s idea of...
  7. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    “It is just as wrong to only breed for working with little regard for conformation” I used to believe that too, but I’m not so sure any more. It’s very difficult to argue with the success of the Belgian Malinois, a breed whose conformation has been considered somewhat irrelevant. It’s also...
  8. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    I tried to find some links that show the history of AKC vs. Schutzhund. Interestingly, the long, sordid history of the AKC’s efforts to prevent Schutzhund from gaining a foothold in the USA is not well documented online. Back when I first became interested in working dogs, it was common...
  9. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    “not having working dog sports supported by AKC did far more to harm than all the conformation in the world” We agree and disagree at the same time on this. Yes, lack of support by the AKC has been the major roadblock to holding working trials and/or working title registration requirements...
  10. A

    A discussion on Temperament

    I agree whole heartedly that the definition of a “good” or “bad” temperament is breed specific and must be tied to the reason a breed exists in the first place. I disagree with blaming AR groups for the loss of temperament in the protection breeds. The Conformation/Show aficionados have done...
  11. A

    How do you introduce your Doberman to new fearful neighbors?

    How to introduce your Dobermann to a new fearful neighbor- Step 1- Muzzle dog. 2- Put dog on a down-stay. 3-Invite neighbor in. 4- Shake hands with neighbor, make small talk. 5- Tell dog “OK, come say hi” 6- Dog then leaps off the floor with a mighty snarl and body slams the neighbor...
  12. A

    How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

    After re-reading what I wrote, it seems like there is still too much room for misunderstanding. Sharpness is a concept that's not easily conveyed. Perhaps "willing" and "reluctant" are better terms to use instead of "quick" and "slow"? One must take thresholds into consideration when determining...
  13. A

    How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

    Quote Matt Vandart- “Sharpness is a dog that will behave forwardly aggressive, surely that is it? It's not complicated really. “ Yes! This is a very basic, simplified meaning of “Sharp”. Now separate the reasons WHY a dog may be forwardly aggressive from the sharpness itself. A dog CAN be...
  14. A

    How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

    Hmmm… one might argue that redirected aggression is simply an expression of frustration. IMO redirection or frustration can manifest itself even in a dog that would not typically be called sharp. There may be a higher likelihood of seeing redirected aggression with a sharp dog, but I don’t...
  15. A

    How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

    “Sharp” or “Sharpness” are English translations of temperament concepts originating in another language/culture/time. It might be impossible to establish a clear definition in light of our language, our culture and our point in history. A very simplistic explanation is that a “sharp” dog is...
  16. A

    Link to the IPO changes coming for 2012

    I just got done skimming through the IPO 1 rules. Am I understanding correctly that changes from SchH1 to IPO 1 include that the dog will have to retrieve over an "A" frame in obedience? In protection the dog will run six blinds?

Back
Top