• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Keeping the proper weight on your puppy or dog

Fact is puppies do eat more than any adult dog - The metabolism is every changing and they play very hard then they drop. They need more food for that rapid growth - once they settle down they will eat less. DV I would be concerned if I were only feeding a growing puppy what the adults dogs are eating. If a puppy looks skinny and I can see clearly the rib I would increase the food. Especially if you are feeding raw it is even more criticial to be sure they are getting enough.
 
My advice to people with puppies or young dogs is not to be afraid to feed them well.... BUT,give them as much exercise as possible (preferably off leash)
a chubby puppy is better than a lean puppy...they need all they can get in growing stages..

My advice echo's Iceman's... as does My Veterinary Cardiologist... puppies are not supposed to be 'lean' or 'thin'.. unless that IS their phenotype to be so.... but they should be well filled out and sleek... so keep feeding your puppies and make sure they are well exercised but not overly so... no reason to push a puppy to much too fast.

a chubby puppy is better than a lean puppy...they need all they can get in growing stages..
Thanx Ice.... :ty:perhaps these nay-saying 'ladies' will heed the voice of a male voice of experience instead of a like minded experienced female on this... :furious:
 
Fact is puppies do eat more than any adult dog - The metabolism is every changing and they play very hard then they drop. They need more food for that rapid growth - once they settle down they will eat less. DV I would be concerned if I were only feeding a growing puppy what the adults dogs are eating. If a puppy looks skinny and I can see clearly the rib I would increase the food. Especially if you are feeding raw it is even more criticial to be sure they are getting enough.

My puppy girl is 78lbs at 10 months... did I convince you she was well fed? LOL

My adult dogs get 2 -2.5lbs meat (mostly muscle meat) if I feed only raw... and 1 1/5-2 lbs if I feed kibble in the morning.
 
Baba is 6 months old this week.... (thursday) and he is 73.6 lbs and 24.5" tall
Saava got weighed yesterday.... He was 6 months old on the 17th... so that makes him 6.5mo old now and he was 84.5 lbs on the scale yesterday! Oh yea.. he is a bruiser... so anyone who dislikes, disagrees with the BIG heavy Dobie puppies?

Well for the sake of safety for our Dobes and the standard either side of the continent I guess I will "weigh" in.

If a puppy puts on over 10 lbs in 2 weeks times that is fat not muscle. Having had to work to keep dogs at best performance weight for working and showing sake I will have to ask just how much do you think bones weigh???

There comes a point when we are not talking about healthy growing puppies but being overweight which is detremental to their overall health. Young joints are growing and the more weight and pressure you place on them is not good for those bones and joints.

Are you also saying the standard on both sides of the continent are wrong - A square, compact medium sized dog - Believe you me I am for keeping heaving bone and I have both American and Euro so I am not speaking out about my knowledge based on mastiffs but on the Doberman Pinscher.

Are you saying weight and bulk is the only thing important in the standard because it is all you talk about.

I have to speak for myself but you do not have the right to tell me or anyone on this forum to keep it to ourselves. Unless I missed it and God help us you have not been appointed moderator then I think you should check with the powers that be before making an insulting statement like that. At your age which you so often tell us along with all your vast experience which you often alluede to I am a little shocked at your total lack of understanding and respect for those who have far more experience than you will ever have because your length of time with a breed seems to be about 10 years then you change. I wonder why????

So if you want to post your mastiff looking jowl hanging Dobermans here them please be polite about it - No one until now has insulted you but I guarantee you I am not going to allow you to continue with your insults and not bite back. You have switched sides so many times it makes my head swim and if you want an example just go back and read the thread on the conformation bitch that you thought should do agility and scoffed at the term "form follows funciton" I believe your words were "argue" with me- two months later or so I guess someone got something through your head and so you posted form follows function just like it was your idea from the beginning. You would do wise to speak less and listen more.

Gemma Rose we all want to see nice strong dobermans with nice bone -but I don't want my dobermans to resemble mastiffs which you still seem to prefer. Well I am either headed for the dog house or out the door - I apologize to Jan if I have over stepped my bounds but I am tired of being insulted by someone who obviously has no manners or knowledge about the Doberman and you certainly would not be anyone I would want any advise from. I have forgotten more than you will ever know.
 
I'm moving the reply to this here to keep the other thread on topic.

Suzan: you like everyone else is entitled to opinions and beliefs.... both Judith, Myself and Marko expressed that we DID feel attacked and insulted with regards to teh size of our dogs... NOT just me...
you have found something wrong with nearly every post I have made either here or on Dobermann Station and as shakespeare says "I think thou dost protest too much"....
I am just sayin...

everything else you said is just like the saying goes... opinions are like :censored: we all have one and clearly yours is always visible and or out there for everyone to see/hear...
 
At 6 months the puppies are starting to slow down the growth rate. There is no way 10 lbs in 2 weeks is smart in anyones book. I have had dogs go 105 lbs and 29 inches and that was all American breeding. BUT it is not what I want to keep for breeding and showing. You must understand the standard.

If JanS and Marko felt attacked by anyone especaially me, I guess I missed it. There is nothing wrong with any dog being a little bigger - the problem is when a self proclaimed breeder comes on and spouts it as the best thing since sliced bread. We all produce some dogs that get bigger than the standard - but we do not intentionally BREED for giant dogs.

If I was the one who posted and made them feel insulted then I certainly apologize - as that was never my intention. FYI there is no correct "weigh" in the standard. But common sense tells me that the height and weight must be in porportion. Also FYI "29" inch dogs can acquire there championship as there is no disqualification for height or weight. It would just take more to finish the dog.

You may not be aware but we are seeing some of the same problems arising now in the Euro dogs especially some lines that are producing dogs way over standard. We saw it here when the SA dogs caught on and suddenly everything was over angulated and has so much chest it could barely run.

As far as age goes we all get old and you are well on your way so I would personally not stupe to personal slams. You need to learn to stick to the issues being discussed and not make everything personal.
 
Susan I guess you missed my post. FCI has standard weight for Dobermans. The MAX weight for a male should be 99.2lbs. So any Doberman 100lbs and up is out of the standard in Europe.

From FCI standard :
SIZE AND WEIGHT: SIZE Height at the highest point of withers: Males: 68cm (26.8") to 72cm (28.4"). Bitches: 63cm (24.8") to 68cm (26.8"). Medium size desirable.
WEIGHT Males ca. 40kg (88lbs) to 45kg (99.2lbs). Bitches ca. 32kg (70.5lbs) to 35kg(77.2lbs).
 
Thanks DV -for catching that - I was speaking from the American Standard point of view. Depending on bone density a dog could weigh up to a couple pounds more. But I gurarantee you at 6 mo ths as their growth starts to slow down and bones did not grow 10 lbs in 2 weeks - not safely or in thes best interest of the dog.

I have dogs I work to keep at working weight and I have dogs I struggle to keep up to the weight I like to see them. But I could not in good conscious recommend anyone putting that much weight on any dog in two weeks.
 
Denissov43 said: ↑
Suzan: you like everyone else is entitled to opinions and beliefs.... both Judith, Myself and Marko expressed that we DID feel attacked and insulted with regards to teh size of our dogs... NOT just me...
you have found something wrong with nearly every post I have made either here or on Dobermann Station and as shakespeare says "I think thou dost protest too much"....
I am just sayin...

everything else you said is just like the saying goes... opinions are like :censored: we all have one and clearly yours is always visible and or out there for everyone to see/hear...


You are right, D4E is entitled to her opinion and so are you. But I have to say that her opinion is based on years of experience and a strong commitment to keep the doberman to standard. I have never seen anywhere what your experience is or any foundation for your opinion. Could you please tell us something about the reasons for your opinions and keep the personal stuff out of it. I would just like to see cold hard facts please.
Difference of opinion make for good debate and I have no problem with that. However when you base your argument on attacking with no facts to back up your statements, it makes for a weak debate.​
 
Thanks Paint - Last weekend at the show you had a chnace to see Nikko and Helio together. Helio was heavier than those puppies when I got him. From the weights people have been sending me they have caught up to him for the most part. Nikko did not look much smaller than Helio and was very nicely filled out with nice bone. I have watched Doberman puppies grow and mature for almost 20 years and lines are different.

The foundation of my girls go back to 2 lines - English on top and American on the bottom. They tend to hold consistency during their growing up whereas the Euro seems to go through more stages of change as they grow and certianly what they produce when bred to my Amer/English dogs.

When I brought Shrock in to take me back to some of my American lines he stayed true and held his appearance through growing up and I wanted to strengthen my genotype (breeding like genes to strengthen the odds of stronger points part of which is the phenotype (outward appearance of the dog.) This is why linebreeding is important in having a successful breeding program whether it is showing, working or just a great pet. You have to know when to go out and when to come back in. Shrock brought me back in and I am seeing very good results in both looks and temperament.
 
Susan I guess you missed my post. FCI has standard weight for Dobermans. The MAX weight for a male should be 99.2lbs. So any Doberman 100lbs and up is out of the standard in Europe.

From FCI standard :
SIZE AND WEIGHT: SIZE Height at the highest point of withers: Males: 68cm (26.8") to 72cm (28.4"). Bitches: 63cm (24.8") to 68cm (26.8"). Medium size desirable.
WEIGHT Males ca. 40kg (88lbs) to 45kg (99.2lbs). Bitches ca. 32kg (70.5lbs) to 35kg(77.2lbs).


The standards DO mention weight for both male & females, but if you read more closely you will see that being over the stated weight is NOT penalized in any way like being over size..In fact, the judges preference is towards dogs with substance & weight in Europe.
The standards mention max weight for the male at 45kg (99.2lbs)
I did not see ONE male below 45kg at IDC this year!! (except puppy & junior class)

Maxim di Altobello who was Champion class sieger was 53kg!!

6169792993_db690665d3_z.jpg
 
Thanks Ice - and I will add your dogs are far closer to standard than many of what I am seeing from the photos and shows over there. They are fit, well muscled and powerful looking and do not seem to have an ounce of fat on them. Very nice.

Did you read my post where it seemed we are starting to see some really big rottie looking Dobes over there. Do you see it as the new trend or is that just my impression -?
 
Thanks Ice - and I will add your dogs are far closer to standard than many of what I am seeing from the photos and shows over there. They are fit, well muscled and powerful looking and do not seem to have an ounce of fat on them. Very nice.

First of all thank you for your nice words about my dogs..I do spend a lot of time building them up and even more to maintain that condition..
Almost all written comments they get from judges at shows include the word powerfull or strong..

Did you read my post where it seemed we are starting to see some really big rottie looking Dobes over there. Do you see it as the new trend or is that just my impression -?


No i did not see the post you mention, but i think you must have got the wrong imporession..
 
The standards DO mention weight for both male & females, but if you read more closely you will see that being over the stated weight is NOT penalized in any way like being over size..In fact, the judges preference is towards dogs with substance & weight in Europe.
The standards mention max weight for the male at 45kg (99.2lbs)
I did not see ONE male below 45kg at IDC this year!! (except puppy & junior class)
Maybe you know Kerber King (he is my pup's father and had few Balkans titles) and I really wondered how could he have titles with his HUGE size, but now it is more clear for me.
 
OMG!!! I finally had to stop reading!! All of this because I made a comment that I keep my dogs lean. OMG!!!! My dogs are not underweight, they are in excellent shape- from my puppies to my adults. They eat what they need to maintain proper weight and condition. PUPPIES CAN BE TOO FAT!!! I would love to see the research that says a FAT puppy is healthier that a puppy at the proper weight. (not compared to an emaciated pupy, a normal puppy) It is not a set amount for a set weight. Every dog burns calories at a different rate. And the "number" is NOT IMPORTANT!!! Just as in people. Every dog has it's ideal weight, one dog at 80 pounds is fat, another is thin, another is perfect! FAT IS NOT HEALTHY!! Whether they are Euro or American or Martian! Emaciated is NOT HEALTHY! My dogs are all Euro, large bone structure and well muscled-= NOT FAT! my puppies do not have to be sausages to be healthy. Puppies with bones sticking out are not healthy.Puppies need at least 2 - 3 times what an adult needs. I follow my VETERINARIANS advice, a person that has spent 8 years or MORE learning how to take care of animals and even longer in practice.

I really wish every one would stop being so defensive. Every comment is not meant as a slam! Keep your dogs healthy, keep them at a good HEALTHY weight, and love them! Don't take everything so personal. Most of us do not want to fight, WE JUST WANT TO TALK TO AND COMPARE NOTES WITH OTHER DOBERMAN LOVERS!!
Can't we all just get along :bump:
 
The standards DO mention weight for both male & females, but if you read more closely you will see that being over the stated weight is NOT penalized in any way like being over size..In fact, the judges preference is towards dogs with substance & weight in Europe.
The standards mention max weight for the male at 45kg (99.2lbs)
I did not see ONE male below 45kg at IDC this year!! (except puppy & junior class)

Maxim di Altobello who was Champion class sieger was 53kg!!

6169792993_db690665d3_z.jpg

Now I know why Maxim is not a winner. He is too heavy :shock:
I don't believe bigger is better. Our breed should be agile and gracious... not heavy like Mastiffs.
 
DV you got it right on the nose. The bigger the dog the less agile, qickness, speed is lost. When we throw caution to the wind to promote our own likes instead of the standard we miss the mark. I know what April means by lean - LEAN MEAN power packed machine. Not lunbering slow slothfull slug. In no way did she ever indicate THIN.

BTW glad you came back in April - the waters fine!!!
 

Back
Top